Guardians Edge Tigers in Extra-Inning Thriller
Tuesday, September 16, 2025, 6:40 PM ET · Comerica Park
Cleveland Guardians 7, Detroit Tigers 5, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Cleveland Guardians vs Detroit Tigers?
Cleveland Guardians beat Detroit Tigers 7-5 at Comerica Park on September 16, 2025.
In a gripping contest at Comerica Park, the Cleveland Guardians triumphed over the Detroit Tigers with a final score of 7-5 after ten innings. This victory allowed the Guardians to secure the series with a dominant 6-1 record against the Tigers this season.
The Guardians have been in impressive form, boasting a record of 9-1 in their last ten games, with a current winning streak of four. They averaged 4.0 runs scored per game while allowing just 1.5 runs. Their recent performances included a narrow 3-2 victory against the Chicago White Sox just two days prior, showcasing their ability to win close games.
In contrast, the Tigers have struggled recently, holding a 5-5 record in their last ten games, with their latest performance being a win against the Miami Marlins. They have averaged 5.5 runs scored per game but have allowed 4.1 runs, indicating a need for improvement in their pitching. The Tigers' home record stands at 2-2 in their last four games, while they have a 3-3 record in their last six away games.
Historically, the matchup between these two teams has been closely contested, with an even split of 10 wins each over their last 20 meetings, including games from the 2024 and 2025 seasons. The Guardians had previously dominated the Tigers in their last three encounters before this game, winning decisively with scores of 7-2, 1-0, and 2-1.
In terms of injuries, the Tigers faced significant challenges with several key players on the injured list, including Burch Smith, Brant Hurter, Wenceel Perez, Jack Flaherty, and Justin Verlander. The Guardians also had players sidelined, including Slade Cecconi, Rhys Hoskins, and Shawn Armstrong, which impacted both teams' lineups.
The market had priced the game with the Tigers as underdogs, reflecting their recent struggles and the Guardians' strong form. The odds were provided by an unnamed sportsbook, indicating a clear expectation for the Guardians to perform well.
The game unfolded with a tense atmosphere, with both teams exchanging leads. The Tigers initially fell behind in the sixth inning when Naylor doubled to right, allowing Ramírez to score and Manzardo to reach third base, pushing the Guardians ahead 3-1. However, the Tigers responded quickly, with Dingler grounding into a fielder's choice that brought Greene home, narrowing the gap to 3-2.
As the game progressed into the ninth inning, Carpenter hit a crucial homer to center, tying the game at 3-3 and sending it into extra innings. The tension escalated in the tenth inning when Kwan doubled to right, scoring Rocchio and putting the Guardians back in the lead. Martínez then tripled to center, allowing Kwan to score, followed by Ramírez hitting a ground rule double that brought Martínez home. The Guardians extended their lead to 7-3 before Torkelson hit a homer for the Tigers, bringing the final score to 7-5.
Fans watching the game should have noted the strategic decisions made by both managers, particularly in the late innings when pitching changes and batting orders were crucial. The ability of the Guardians to capitalize on their opportunities in extra innings was a key factor in their victory, demonstrating their resilience and depth as a team.
Injury report
- Burch Smith60-Day-ILShoulderDetroit Tigers
- Brant Hurter60-Day-ILBackDetroit Tigers
- Wenceel Perez60-Day-ILOrbitalDetroit Tigers
- Jack Flaherty15-Day-ILForearmDetroit Tigers
- Justin Verlander60-Day-ILHamstringDetroit Tigers
- Slade Cecconi15-Day-ILArmCleveland Guardians
- Rhys Hoskins10-Day-ILBackCleveland Guardians
- Shawn Armstrong60-Day-ILCalfCleveland Guardians
Recent form
Detroit Tigers
Last 10: 5-5Streak W15.5 scored · 4.1 allowed per game2-2 at home
- W2-0at Miami MarlinsSep 14
- L4-6at Miami MarlinsSep 13
- L2-8at Miami MarlinsSep 12
- L3-9at New York YankeesSep 11
- W11-1at New York YankeesSep 10
- W12-2at New York YankeesSep 9
- L4-6vs Chicago White SoxSep 7
- W6-0vs Chicago White SoxSep 6
- L5-7vs Chicago White SoxSep 5
- W6-2vs New York MetsSep 3
Cleveland Guardians
Last 10: 9-1Streak W44 scored · 1.5 allowed per game3-0 away
- W3-2vs Chicago White SoxSep 14
- W3-1vs Chicago White SoxSep 13
- W4-0vs Chicago White SoxSep 12
- W3-2vs Kansas City RoyalsSep 11
- L3-4vs Kansas City RoyalsSep 10
- W2-0vs Kansas City RoyalsSep 9
- W10-2vs Kansas City RoyalsSep 8
- W2-1at Tampa Bay RaysSep 7
- W3-2at Tampa Bay RaysSep 6
- W7-1at Tampa Bay RaysSep 5
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicago | - | 66 | L1 | .525 | 73 |
| Cleveland | 3 | 69 | L1 | .504 | 70 |
| Minnesota | 6.5 | 73 | L1 | .479 | 67 |
| Detroit | 9 | 75 | W1 | .460 | 64 |
| Kansas City | 11.5 | 78 | L3 | .443 | 62 |
How the scoring went
- 2nd Inning1-0Kayfus singled to right, Jones scored.
- 3rd Inning1-1Torres homered to left (402 feet).
- 4th Inning2-1Arias homered to right center (412 feet).
- 6th Inning3-1Naylor doubled to right, Ramírez scored, Manzardo to third.
- 6th Inning3-2Dingler grounded into fielder's choice to third, Greene scored, Keith out at second.
- 9th Inning3-3Carpenter homered to center (429 feet).
- 10th Inning4-3Kwan doubled to right, Rocchio scored.
- 10th Inning5-3Martínez tripled to center, Kwan scored.
- 10th Inning6-3Ramírez hit a ground rule double, Martínez scored.
- 10th Inning7-3Arias singled to right, Ramírez scored, Arias to second, Manzardo to third.
- 10th Inning7-5Torkelson homered to left center (401 feet), Torres scored.
Win probability
Above the line favours Detroit Tigers, below favours Cleveland Guardians.
Venue
- Comerica ParkDetroit, Michigan
- Attendance31639
- OfficialsJeremie Rehak, Tom Hanahan, Chris Conroy, Brennan Miller
Elsewhere
- Dodgers' Roberts says Ohtani 'visibly' ailing after 0-for-4 night
- 2026 MLB ABS challenge system tracker: Team, player rankings
- Saggese hits go-ahead single in the 10th in the Cardinals' 8-6 victory over the Dodgers
- St. Louis Cardinals vs. Los Angeles Dodgers: Game Highlights
- Schlittler sharp, the Yankees score 5 2-out runs in the 10th in a 6-3 win over the Angels
- New York Yankees vs. Los Angeles Angels: Game Highlights