Brewers Edge Pirates in Close Contest
Wednesday, September 16, 2026, 6:40 PM ET · PNC Park
Milwaukee Brewers 5, Pittsburgh Pirates 4, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Milwaukee Brewers vs Pittsburgh Pirates?
Milwaukee Brewers beat Pittsburgh Pirates 5-4 at PNC Park on September 16, 2026.
Who was favored in Milwaukee Brewers vs Pittsburgh Pirates?
Milwaukee Brewers were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -135 (about 57% implied). The favorite won.
In a tightly contested game at PNC Park, the Milwaukee Brewers narrowly defeated the Pittsburgh Pirates 5-4. This match was significant as it marked the Brewers' continued dominance over the Pirates in their current series, extending their lead to 3-0. The Brewers have now outscored the Pirates 15-5 in their last three encounters, showcasing their offensive prowess against a struggling Pittsburgh team.
The Brewers came into this game with a strong recent form, boasting a record of 7-3 over their last 10 games. They have averaged 7.8 runs scored per game while allowing 5.0 runs, indicating a potent offense complemented by a shaky pitching staff. Their last outing against the Pirates resulted in a convincing 5-1 victory, further solidifying their confidence. The Pirates, on the other hand, have struggled, recording a 6-4 record in their last 10 games, with an average of 2.8 runs scored and 3.5 runs allowed. They have lost their last game against the Brewers and are on a one-game losing streak.
At home, the Pirates have managed a 2-2 record in their last four games, while their away performance has seen them go 4-2. The Brewers have fared well on the road with a 2-2 record in their last four away games, but their overall away record stands at 5-1 in their last six games. This fixture highlighted the contrasting fortunes of the two teams as they approached the final stretch of the season.
In terms of head-to-head matchups, the Pirates have struggled against the Brewers recently, with a record of 8-15-1 in their last 24 meetings. The previous encounters in the current season saw the Pirates lose three straight games to the Brewers, with scores of 1-5, 2-5, and 2-4. The Pirates' only win against the Brewers this season came on August 3, when they triumphed 4-3.
Injuries played a crucial role in this matchup, particularly for the Pirates, who were missing several key players. Kirby Yates, Braxton Ashcraft, Isaac Mattson, Esmerlyn Valdez, and Mitch Keller were all on the injured list, impacting the team's depth and performance. The Brewers also faced injury challenges, with Rob Zastryzny on the 60-day IL and Garrett Mitchell listed as day-to-day with a neck issue. Bryse Wilson and Grant Anderson were also on the 15-day IL, while Brandon Woodruff remained on the 60-day IL.
The betting odds from DraftKings reflected the Brewers' status as favorites, with a money line of -135, while the Pirates were at +112. The spread was set at 1.5, and the total runs over/under was listed at 7.5. These odds indicated a strong belief in the Brewers' ability to secure a win, given their recent form and overall record.
The game conditions were favorable for both teams, with clear skies and a comfortable temperature, allowing for an exciting display of baseball. Fans were treated to a back-and-forth battle, with significant plays that kept the outcome in suspense until the final moments.
The scoring plays were pivotal in determining the outcome of the game. The Brewers struck first in the second inning, with Vaughn singling to left, allowing Ortiz to score. This was followed by Pratt's single, which brought Lara home, giving the Brewers an early 2-0 lead. The Pirates responded in the fourth inning when Cruz homered to right, cutting the deficit to 2-1. The fifth inning saw Turang double to center, scoring Pratt and extending the Brewers' lead to 3-1.
However, the Pirates fought back, with Lowe hitting a homer to right, bringing the game to a 3-3 tie. The Pirates then took the lead in the sixth inning when Flores Jr. hit another homer, making it 4-3. But the Brewers were not to be outdone; in the seventh inning, Yelich's single allowed Bauers and Chourio to score, sealing the game at 5-4 in favor of Milwaukee.
This game showcased the competitive spirit of both teams, with the Brewers ultimately securing the victory through timely hitting and resilient play. As the season progresses, the Brewers will look to maintain their momentum, while the Pirates will need to regroup and address their recent struggles.
What we said beforehand
The Pittsburgh Pirates will face the Milwaukee Brewers at PNC Park on September 16, 2026, with the Brewers leading the series 1-0 after a recent victory. This matchup is significant as the Brewers currently hold a strong record of 94-57, while the Pirates sit at 75-76. The game is set to start at 22:40 UTC, and fans can expect a warm evening with a temperature of 85°F and a 47% chance of precipitation, alongside wind gusts reaching 6 mph.
In their recent form, the Pirates have struggled, winning only two of their last five games. Their latest results include a win against the Chicago White Sox (2-0) but losses to the Chicago Cubs (12-2, 4-3) and the Brewers (1-5). Over their last ten games, they have a record of 6-4, averaging 2.8 runs scored and allowing 3.5 runs per game. Notably, they have been inconsistent at home, with a home record of 2-2 in their last four games.
Conversely, the Brewers have been on a roll, winning four of their last five games. Their recent victories include a win against the Pirates (5-1) and a strong performance against the Cincinnati Reds (20-0, 13-9). The Brewers have an impressive record of 7-3 over their last ten games, averaging 7.8 runs scored and allowing 5.0 runs per game. They have also performed well on the road, with a 2-2 record away from home in their last four games.
In terms of head-to-head matchups, the Pirates have struggled against the Brewers, with a record of 8-15-1 in their last 24 meetings. The most recent encounter saw the Pirates lose 1-5 at home, adding to their challenges against Milwaukee this season. Previous meetings have also favored the Brewers, with the Pirates only managing to win once in their last five encounters.
Injury concerns could impact the Pirates' performance, as they will be without Kirby Yates, Braxton Ashcraft, Isaac Mattson, Esmerlyn Valdez, and Mitch Keller, all of whom are on the injured list. The Brewers also face some injury issues, with Rob Zastryzny on the 60-Day IL and Bryse Wilson and Grant Anderson on the 15-Day IL. Garrett Mitchell is listed as day-to-day with a neck issue, which could affect his availability.
The betting market reflects the Brewers' current form, with DraftKings listing them at -130 on the moneyline, while the Pirates are at +108. The spread is set at 1.5 runs, and the total runs for the game are set at 7.5, with odds of -120 for the under and +100 for the over.
As the game approaches, viewers should watch for key players such as Nick Gonzales, who leads the Pirates with a batting average of .307, and Brandon Lowe, who has hit 30 home runs and driven in 86 runs. For the Brewers, Jackson Chourio boasts a .289 batting average, while Jake Bauers has contributed 26 home runs. With both teams vying for crucial wins, this matchup promises to deliver excitement and competitive baseball.
Odds
| Book | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| DraftKings | MIL -135 | 7.5 o -102 / u -118 | Milwaukee Brewers -135 · Pittsburgh Pirates +112 |
Injury report
- Kirby Yates15-Day-ILShoulderPittsburgh Pirates
- Braxton Ashcraft15-Day-ILArmPittsburgh Pirates
- Isaac Mattson15-Day-ILHipPittsburgh Pirates
- Esmerlyn Valdez10-Day-ILHamstringPittsburgh Pirates
- Mitch Keller60-Day-ILArmPittsburgh Pirates
- Rob Zastryzny60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Garrett MitchellDay-To-DayNeckMilwaukee Brewers
- Bryse Wilson15-Day-ILBackMilwaukee Brewers
- Grant Anderson15-Day-ILBicepsMilwaukee Brewers
- Brandon Woodruff60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
Recent form
Pittsburgh Pirates
Last 10: 6-4Streak L12.8 scored · 3.5 allowed per game2-2 at home
- L1-5vs Milwaukee BrewersSep 15
- W4-3at Chicago CubsSep 13
- L3-4at Chicago CubsSep 12
- L2-12at Chicago CubsSep 11
- W2-0at Chicago White SoxSep 10
- W4-2at Chicago White SoxSep 9
- W9-3at Chicago White SoxSep 8
- W1-0vs Los Angeles AngelsSep 6
- L1-6vs Los Angeles AngelsSep 5
- W1-0vs Los Angeles AngelsSep 4
Milwaukee Brewers
Last 10: 7-3Streak W17.8 scored · 5 allowed per game2-2 away
- W5-1at Pittsburgh PiratesSep 15
- L3-4vs Cincinnati RedsSep 13
- W13-9vs Cincinnati RedsSep 12
- W20-0vs Cincinnati RedsSep 11
- W8-6vs Chicago CubsSep 9
- W4-3vs Chicago CubsSep 8
- W4-3vs Chicago CubsSep 7
- L8-12at Cincinnati RedsSep 6
- L3-5at Cincinnati RedsSep 5
- W10-7at Cincinnati RedsSep 4
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee | - | 57 | W2 | .625 | 95 |
| Chicago | 11 | 68 | L1 | .553 | 84 |
| Pittsburgh | 20 | 77 | L2 | .493 | 75 |
| St. Louis | 20.5 | 78 | L2 | .490 | 75 |
| Cincinnati | 24 | 81 | W1 | .467 | 71 |
How the scoring went
- 2nd Inning1-0Vaughn singled to left, Ortiz scored, Lara to second.
- 2nd Inning2-0Pratt singled to center, Lara scored, Pratt to second, Vaughn to third.
- 4th Inning2-1Cruz homered to right (391 feet).
- 5th Inning3-1Turang doubled to center, Pratt scored.
- 5th Inning3-3Lowe homered to right (418 feet), Griffin scored.
- 6th Inning3-4Flores Jr. homered to right center (407 feet).
- 7th Inning5-4Yelich singled to left, Bauers scored and Chourio scored, Contreras to second.
Win probability
Above the line favours Pittsburgh Pirates, below favours Milwaukee Brewers.
Venue
- PNC ParkPittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- Attendance11393
- OfficialsD.J. Reyburn, James Hoye, Sean Barber, John Libka
Elsewhere
- Nick Martinez gets 15th win as Rays beat Athletics 4-3 for 5th straight victory
- Pete Alonso's latest Citi Field homer draws another ovation
- Mets' Robert Stock done for season due to numbness in his fingers
- Dodgers' Blake Snell (groin) exits vs. Reds after one inning
- Kurkjian in Aaron Judge’s latest injury: Yankees are being ‘very careful’
- Twins top Yankees 5-4 in 13 innings on Caratini's single after Judge leaves early with leg tightness
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Pirates Defeat Brewers 7-4 in Final Game of SeriesSep 17, 2026
- Brewers Defeat Pirates 5-1 at PNC ParkSep 15, 2026
- Brewers Secure Series Victory Over Pirates with 5-2 WinAug 6, 2026
- Brewers Secure Series Win Over Pirates with 4-2 VictoryAug 5, 2026
- Brewers Secure Series Win Over Pirates with 4-2 VictoryAug 4, 2026