Mets Dominate Yankees in Rivalry Clash
Saturday, September 12, 2026, 1:35 PM ET · Yankee Stadium
New York Mets 12, New York Yankees 2, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won New York Mets vs New York Yankees?
New York Mets beat New York Yankees 12-2 at Yankee Stadium on September 12, 2026.
Who was favored in New York Mets vs New York Yankees?
New York Yankees were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -171 (about 63% implied). The underdog won.
The New York Mets delivered a resounding performance against the New York Yankees, winning decisively with a final score of 12-2 at Yankee Stadium. This game was particularly noteworthy as it marked the conclusion of a three-game series that was tied 1-1 prior to this matchup. The Mets' victory not only showcased their offensive prowess but also highlighted the Yankees' struggles, particularly in the context of their recent form.
In the lead-up to this game, the Yankees had been on a solid run, boasting a record of 7-3 in their last ten games with a four-game winning streak. They had averaged 6.2 runs scored per game while allowing only 3.5 runs. However, the Mets were equally impressive, also holding a 7-3 record in their last ten games, though they were coming off a loss, which snapped a three-game winning streak. The Mets averaged 6.9 runs scored per game but allowed 5.8 runs, indicating a more volatile defensive performance compared to the Yankees.
At home, the Yankees had a strong record of 5-0 in their last five games, while their away record stood at 2-3. The Mets, on the other hand, had performed well on the road with a 5-2 record in their last seven away games, which included a recent win against the Miami Marlins. This game was crucial for both teams as they vied for positioning in the standings, with the Yankees holding an 85-63 record compared to the Mets' 69-79.
The rivalry between the Yankees and Mets, known as the Subway Series, has been characterized by closely contested games. In their last ten meetings, the teams were evenly matched at 5-5. This season alone, they had faced off three times prior to this game, with the Yankees winning two of those encounters. However, the Mets turned the tide in this latest matchup, demonstrating their ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities and maintain pressure throughout the game.
In terms of injuries, the Yankees were dealing with several key players on the injured list, including Clarke Schmidt, Ryan Weathers, Fernando Cruz, Trent Grisham, and Giancarlo Stanton. The Mets also had their share of injuries, with Brett Baty listed as day-to-day due to a knee issue, while Cionel Perez, Devin Williams, Jorge Polanco, and Reed Garrett were on the injured list. The absence of these players undoubtedly affected both teams' lineups and strategies.
The betting odds from DraftKings reflected the Yankees as favorites at -171, with a spread of -1.5 and a total set at 8.0. The Mets were listed at +141 on the money line, indicating that the market expected a competitive game. However, the outcome revealed a significant gap in performance, with the Mets easily surpassing the total runs expected.
Weather conditions were typical for a September evening in New York, providing a favorable environment for baseball. Fans at Yankee Stadium witnessed a series of impressive plays and home runs that contributed to the Mets' commanding lead.
The scoring plays were a highlight of the game, with Benge homering to right center in the third inning, giving the Mets an early edge. The Yankees managed to respond with a run in the fourth inning, but the Mets quickly regained control. Notable performances included Bellinger, who contributed significantly with a single that allowed Goldschmidt to score, and later hit a home run himself. Soto's powerful homer in the seventh inning further extended the Mets' lead, while Lindor's grand slam in the eighth inning effectively sealed the game.
As the game progressed, it became clear that the Mets were in control, with their offense overwhelming the Yankees' pitching staff. The Yankees struggled to find their rhythm, and despite their recent strong performances, this game served as a stark reminder of the challenges they face as they approach the end of the season. The Mets' victory not only gave them a crucial win in the rivalry but also showcased their potential as they look to finish the season strong.
What we said beforehand
The New York Yankees will face off against the New York Mets at Yankee Stadium on September 12, 2026, with the Yankees currently leading the series 1-0 after their recent 6-4 victory over the Mets on September 11. This matchup is particularly compelling as both teams are vying for favorable positioning as the season nears its conclusion, with the Yankees holding a strong record of 85-62 compared to the Mets' 68-79.
In their last five games, the Yankees have secured four wins, including three consecutive victories against the Colorado Rockies before their latest win against the Mets. They have averaged 6.0 runs scored and allowed only 3.0 runs per game during this stretch. Meanwhile, the Mets have also performed well recently, winning four of their last five games, with an impressive average of 7.8 runs scored per game, although they allowed 6.2 runs on average. Their recent form includes a high-scoring affair against the Miami Marlins, where they won 15-14, but they fell short against the Yankees in their last encounter.
At home, the Yankees have been particularly strong, boasting a record of 7-3 in their last ten games, with an impressive home scoring average of 6.2 runs and only 3.5 runs allowed. They are currently on a four-game winning streak at Yankee Stadium. In contrast, the Mets have a mixed away record of 5-2 in their last seven away games, with an average of 6.9 runs scored but a higher average of 5.8 runs allowed.
Historically, the Yankees and Mets have been evenly matched in their recent meetings, with a head-to-head record of 5-5 over the last two seasons. The Yankees won the last encounter, while the Mets had previously taken two out of three games in their earlier meetings this season.
In terms of injuries, the Yankees will be missing several key players, including Clarke Schmidt and Giancarlo Stanton, both on the injured list for significant periods. The Mets also have notable absences, including Jorge Polanco and Cionel Perez, which could impact their performance.
The betting market, as provided by DraftKings, has the Yankees favored at -170 on the money line, with a spread of -1.5 and a total set at 8.0 runs. The over odds are at -114.0, while the under odds are at -105.0.
Weather conditions for the game are expected to be warm, with a temperature around 79°F and no precipitation forecasted, alongside gusts of wind at 10 mph. Fans can expect an exciting matchup as both teams look to assert their dominance in this New York rivalry.
Odds
| Book | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| DraftKings | NYY -171 | 8 o -114 / u -105 | New York Mets +141 · New York Yankees -171 |
Injury report
- Clarke Schmidt60-Day-ILElbowNew York Yankees
- Ryan Weathers15-Day-ILForearmNew York Yankees
- Fernando Cruz15-Day-ILElbowNew York Yankees
- Trent Grisham10-Day-ILHamstringNew York Yankees
- Giancarlo Stanton60-Day-ILCalfNew York Yankees
- Brett BatyDay-To-DayKneeNew York Mets
- Cionel Perez15-Day-ILForearmNew York Mets
- Devin Williams15-Day-ILShoulderNew York Mets
- Jorge Polanco60-Day-ILAnkleNew York Mets
- Reed Garrett60-Day-ILElbowNew York Mets
Recent form
New York Yankees
Last 10: 7-3Streak W46.2 scored · 3.5 allowed per game5-0 at home
- W6-4vs New York MetsSep 11
- W10-3vs Colorado RockiesSep 10
- W6-1vs Colorado RockiesSep 9
- W5-3vs Colorado RockiesSep 8
- L3-4at San Diego PadresSep 6
- L2-3at San Diego PadresSep 5
- W6-3at Los Angeles AngelsSep 3
- W7-3at Los Angeles AngelsSep 2
- L1-10at Los Angeles AngelsSep 1
- W16-1vs Boston Red SoxAug 30
New York Mets
Last 10: 7-3Streak L16.9 scored · 5.8 allowed per game5-2 away
- L4-6at New York YankeesSep 11
- W15-14at Miami MarlinsSep 9
- W7-5at Miami MarlinsSep 8
- W9-4at Miami MarlinsSep 7
- W4-2vs San Francisco GiantsSep 6
- L5-9vs San Francisco GiantsSep 5
- W10-6vs San Francisco GiantsSep 4
- W10-4at Tampa Bay RaysSep 2
- L2-6at Tampa Bay RaysSep 1
- W3-2at Tampa Bay RaysAug 31
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atlanta | - | 61 | W2 | .588 | 87 |
| Philadelphia | 5 | 66 | L2 | .554 | 82 |
| Miami | 15 | 76 | L4 | .486 | 72 |
| New York | 18 | 79 | W1 | .466 | 69 |
| Washington | 19.5 | 81 | W1 | .456 | 68 |
| Tampa Bay | - | 59 | W1 | .599 | 88 |
| New York | 3.5 | 63 | L1 | .574 | 85 |
| Boston | 8.5 | 68 | L3 | .541 | 80 |
| Toronto | 15.5 | 75 | L2 | .493 | 73 |
| Baltimore | 16.5 | 76 | W2 | .486 | 72 |
How the scoring went
- 1st Inning1-0Lindor homered to right (359 feet).
- 2nd Inning3-0Torrens homered to left (387 feet), Young scored.
- 3rd Inning4-0Benge homered to right center (368 feet).
- 4th Inning4-1Bellinger singled to right, Goldschmidt scored.
- 5th Inning5-1Benge singled to center, Soto scored.
- 6th Inning5-2Bellinger homered to right center (364 feet).
- 7th Inning6-2Soto homered to right center (400 feet).
- 8th Inning7-2Torrens doubled to left, Semien scored, Ewing to third.
- 8th Inning11-2Lindor homered to right center (365 feet), Ewing scored, Torrens scored and Morabito scored.
- 9th Inning12-2Young homered to right (365 feet).
Win probability
Above the line favours New York Yankees, below favours New York Mets.
Venue
- Yankee StadiumBronx, New York
- Attendance46864
- OfficialsLance Barrett, Willie Traynor, Jansen Visconti, Nick Mahrley
Elsewhere
- New York Mets vs. New York Yankees: Game Highlights
- Fantasy baseball lineup Sunday advice: Justin Wrobleski, Noah Cameron stand out as streamers
- Dodgers' Freeman in lineup after missing 2 games with knee issue
- Cubs activate Edward Cabrera from IL, move him to bullpen
- Pirates place rookie Esmerlyn Valdez (hamstring) on 10-day IL
- MLB betting tips for Saturday: Fade Murakami, Peters at Busch Stadium
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Yankees Secure Series Win Over Mets with 2-0 VictorySep 13, 2026
- Yankees Edge Mets in Close Battle at Yankee StadiumSep 11, 2026
- Mets Edge Yankees in Thrilling 10-Inning ShowdownMay 17, 2026
- Mets Secure Series Victory Over Yankees with 6-3 WinMay 16, 2026
- Yankees Defeat Mets in Citi Field ShowdownMay 15, 2026