Brewers Edge Yankees in Thrilling Extra-Inning Showdown
Saturday, May 9, 2026, 7:10 PM ET · American Family Field
Milwaukee Brewers 4, New York Yankees 3, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won New York Yankees vs Milwaukee Brewers?
Milwaukee Brewers beat New York Yankees 4-3 at American Family Field on May 9, 2026.
Who was favored in New York Yankees vs Milwaukee Brewers?
New York Yankees were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -136 (about 58% implied). The underdog won.
In a gripping extra-inning battle, the Milwaukee Brewers triumphed over the New York Yankees with a final score of 4-3, clinching the series 3-0. The game, held at American Family Field, showcased the Brewers' resilience, particularly as they came back from a deficit to secure the win in the 10th inning.
The Brewers entered the game with a home record of 21-16, having recently displayed strong form with a record of 6-3-1 over their last ten games. They were on a two-game winning streak, averaging 5.5 runs scored while allowing only 2.2 runs per game during that stretch. Their last match before facing the Yankees was a decisive 6-0 victory against the same team, highlighting their current competitive edge.
Conversely, the New York Yankees boasted a better overall record of 26-14, though they had recently stumbled, losing their last game against the Brewers. Their recent form showed an 8-2 record over the last ten games, but they were coming off a loss, averaging 6.3 runs scored and 3.2 runs allowed per game in that span. The Yankees had a strong start to the season, but the loss against the Brewers marked the end of a successful run.
In terms of home and away performance, the Brewers had a solid home record of 3-1 in their last four games, while the Yankees had a mixed away record of 2-1 in their last three games. Previous meetings between the two teams in the current season had heavily favored the Brewers, who had outscored the Yankees 12-6 over their last three encounters.
Injuries played a significant role in the matchup, with the Brewers missing several key players, including Rob Zastryzny, Bryse Wilson, Brandon Woodruff, Quinn Priester, and Angel Zerpa, all on the injured list. The Yankees were also dealing with injuries, notably Aaron Judge, who is on the 60-day injured list due to rib issues, along with Clarke Schmidt and Giancarlo Stanton, both sidelined with elbow and calf injuries, respectively. George Lombard Jr. was listed as day-to-day with a knee issue, adding uncertainty to the Yankees' lineup.
The betting market, as provided by DraftKings, favored the Yankees with odds of -136, while the Brewers had odds of +113. The spread was set at 1.5, with the total runs expected at 7.5, indicating a competitive matchup anticipated by bettors.
The game conditions were typical for a spring evening in Milwaukee, providing a fitting backdrop for an exciting contest. Fans were treated to a display of skill and determination from both teams, with the Brewers ultimately prevailing in a thrilling finish.
The scoring plays unfolded dramatically throughout the game. The Yankees took an early lead in the first inning when Paul Goldschmidt homered to left center, marking the first run of the night. By the fourth inning, they extended their lead to 2-0 as Goldschmidt reached on an infield single, allowing Rosario to score. The Brewers responded in the eighth inning when Willson Contreras singled to left, bringing Turang home and tying the game at 2-2.
The tension escalated in the 10th inning when the Yankees scored again, with McMahon's single driving Schuemann home. However, the Brewers answered back quickly, with Chourio reaching on an infield single to tie the game at 3-3. In a dramatic conclusion, Contreras hit a sacrifice fly that allowed Rengifo to score, sealing the victory for the Brewers at 4-3.
This game exemplified the competitive spirit of both teams and highlighted the Brewers' ability to perform under pressure, especially in front of their home crowd. As the season progresses, both teams will look to build on this matchup, with the Brewers continuing to capitalize on their home advantage.
Odds
| Book | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| DraftKings | NYY -136 | 7.5 o -113 / u -107 | New York Yankees -136 · Milwaukee Brewers +113 |
Injury report
- Rob Zastryzny60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Bryse Wilson15-Day-ILBackMilwaukee Brewers
- Brandon Woodruff60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Quinn Priester60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Angel Zerpa60-Day-ILElbowMilwaukee Brewers
- George Lombard Jr.Day-To-DayKneeNew York Yankees
- Aaron Judge60-Day-ILRibsNew York Yankees
- Clarke Schmidt60-Day-ILElbowNew York Yankees
- Ryan Weathers15-Day-ILForearmNew York Yankees
- Giancarlo Stanton60-Day-ILCalfNew York Yankees
Recent form
Milwaukee Brewers
Last 10: 6-3-1Streak W25.5 scored · 2.2 allowed per game3-1 at home
- W6-0vs New York YankeesMay 8
- W6-2at St. Louis CardinalsMay 6
- D0-0at St. Louis CardinalsMay 5
- L3-6at St. Louis CardinalsMay 4
- L2-3at Washington NationalsMay 3
- W4-1at Washington NationalsMay 2
- W6-1at Washington NationalsMay 1
- W13-1vs Arizona DiamondbacksApr 30
- L2-6vs Arizona DiamondbacksApr 29
- W13-2vs Arizona DiamondbacksApr 28
New York Yankees
Last 10: 8-2Streak L16.3 scored · 3.2 allowed per game2-1 away
- L0-6at Milwaukee BrewersMay 8
- W9-2vs Texas RangersMay 7
- L1-6vs Texas RangersMay 6
- W7-4vs Texas RangersMay 5
- W12-1vs Baltimore OriolesMay 4
- W11-3vs Baltimore OriolesMay 3
- W9-4vs Baltimore OriolesMay 2
- W7-2vs Baltimore OriolesMay 1
- W3-2at Texas RangersApr 29
- W4-2at Texas RangersApr 28
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tampa Bay | - | 56 | L1 | .597 | 83 |
| New York | 3.5 | 60 | W2 | .571 | 80 |
| Boston | 8.5 | 65 | L2 | .536 | 75 |
| Toronto | 14.5 | 71 | W1 | .493 | 69 |
| Baltimore | 14.5 | 71 | L2 | .493 | 69 |
| Milwaukee | - | 53 | W2 | .621 | 87 |
| Chicago | 9 | 62 | L2 | .557 | 78 |
| St. Louis | 17 | 70 | W2 | .500 | 70 |
| Pittsburgh | 19 | 72 | L1 | .486 | 68 |
| Cincinnati | 20 | 73 | W2 | .479 | 67 |
How the scoring went
- 1st Inning1-0Goldschmidt homered to left center (419 feet).
- 4th Inning2-0Goldschmidt reached on infield single to third, Rosario scored, Caballero to second, Chisholm Jr. to third.
- 7th Inning2-1Bauers homered to right center (420 feet).
- 8th Inning2-2Contreras singled to left, Turang scored.
- 10th Inning3-2McMahon singled to center, Schuemann scored, Judge thrown out at third.
- 10th Inning3-3Chourio reached on infield single to shortstop, Mitchell scored, Rengifo to second.
- 10th Inning3-4Contreras hit sacrifice fly to right, Rengifo scored.
Win probability
Above the line favours Milwaukee Brewers, below favours New York Yankees.
Venue
- American Family FieldMilwaukee, Wisconsin
- Attendance35628
- OfficialsRoberto Ortiz, Alex Mackay, Tripp Gibson, Alan Porter