Orioles Edge Pirates in Extra-Inning Thriller
Tuesday, September 9, 2025, 6:35 PM ET · Oriole Park at Camden Yards
Baltimore Orioles 3, Pittsburgh Pirates 2, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Pittsburgh Pirates vs Baltimore Orioles?
Baltimore Orioles beat Pittsburgh Pirates 3-2 at Oriole Park at Camden Yards on September 9, 2025.
In a tightly contested matchup, the Baltimore Orioles triumphed over the Pittsburgh Pirates with a final score of 3-2 after 11 innings at Oriole Park at Camden Yards. This victory completed a three-game sweep for the Orioles, who have now won all three games in this series against the Pirates. The game was marked by a series of clutch plays and key moments that kept fans on the edge of their seats.
The Orioles, with a home record of 67-77, have been struggling in recent weeks, holding a 4-6 record over their last ten games, including a loss in their previous outing against the Los Angeles Dodgers. They have averaged 3.2 runs scored while allowing 5.3 runs during this stretch. Despite this, the Orioles managed to rally in this game, showcasing resilience and determination. Their last five games showed a slight improvement, with a record of 4-1 and an average of 3.6 runs scored against 2.8 allowed.
On the other hand, the Pirates, with a record of 64-81, have also been inconsistent lately, posting a 5-5 record in their last ten games but currently on a three-game losing streak. They averaged 3.9 runs scored and allowed 4.3 runs during this period. The Pirates faced the Milwaukee Brewers in their last game, which ended in a significant 2-10 defeat.
In terms of home and away performance, the Orioles have struggled at home with a record of 2-4 in their last six games, while the Pirates have been more balanced, with a home record of 3-3 and an away record of 2-2 in their recent outings.
Historically, the Orioles have faced the Pirates three times this season, with the Orioles winning two of those matchups. Their previous meetings included a close 5-2 victory for the Orioles earlier in the season, followed by two narrow losses for the Orioles at the hands of the Pirates.
Injury concerns have also played a role in both teams' performances. The Orioles were missing several key players, including Tyler O'Neill and Ryan Mountcastle, both on the injured list due to shoulder and oblique issues, respectively. The Pirates also faced challenges, with Konnor Griffin and Mitch Keller among those on the injured list.
The betting market reflected a strong belief in the Orioles' chances, with their win probability at 1.0 at the conclusion of the game, indicating a clear expectation of victory.
The game started with the Pirates taking an early lead in the first inning when Andrew McCutchen singled to left field, scoring Horwitz. However, the Orioles quickly responded with a sacrifice fly from Mountcastle, allowing Holliday to score, leveling the game at 1-1. As the game progressed, the Orioles took a 2-1 lead in the sixth inning when J. Jackson hit a home run to right field.
The Pirates fought back in the ninth inning, tying the game at 2-2 with a home run from Pham, pushing the game into extra innings. In the 11th inning, the Orioles sealed their victory when Basallo singled to left, scoring Henderson and bringing the final score to 3-2.
Fans watching the game were treated to a showcase of late-game drama, with both teams displaying the competitive spirit typical of a closely matched series. The Orioles' ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities in extra innings ultimately proved decisive in this thrilling encounter.
Injury report
- Tyler O'Neill10-Day-ILShoulderBaltimore Orioles
- Felix Bautista60-Day-ILShoulderBaltimore Orioles
- Christian Franklin10-Day-ILHandBaltimore Orioles
- Ryan Helsley60-Day-ILElbowBaltimore Orioles
- Ryan Mountcastle60-Day-ILObliqueBaltimore Orioles
- Konnor Griffin60-Day-ILFingerPittsburgh Pirates
- Ryan O'Hearn10-Day-ILQuadricepsPittsburgh Pirates
- Mitch Keller60-Day-ILArmPittsburgh Pirates
- Endy Rodriguez60-Day-ILHipPittsburgh Pirates
Recent form
Baltimore Orioles
Last 10: 4-6Streak L13.2 scored · 5.3 allowed per game2-4 at home
- L2-5vs Los Angeles DodgersSep 7
- W4-3vs Los Angeles DodgersSep 6
- W2-1vs Los Angeles DodgersSep 5
- W6-2at San Diego PadresSep 3
- W4-3at San Diego PadresSep 1
- L2-13at San Francisco GiantsAug 31
- L8-15at San Francisco GiantsAug 30
- L2-3vs Boston Red SoxAug 28
- L2-3vs Boston Red SoxAug 27
- L0-5vs Boston Red SoxAug 26
Pittsburgh Pirates
Last 10: 5-5Streak L33.9 scored · 4.3 allowed per game2-2 away
- L2-10vs Milwaukee BrewersSep 7
- L1-4vs Milwaukee BrewersSep 6
- L2-5vs Milwaukee BrewersSep 5
- W5-3vs Los Angeles DodgersSep 4
- W3-0vs Los Angeles DodgersSep 3
- W9-7vs Los Angeles DodgersSep 2
- L2-5at Boston Red SoxAug 31
- W10-3at Boston Red SoxAug 30
- W4-2at Boston Red SoxAug 29
- L1-4at St. Louis CardinalsAug 28
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee | - | 53 | W2 | .621 | 87 |
| Chicago | 9 | 62 | L2 | .557 | 78 |
| St. Louis | 17 | 70 | W2 | .500 | 70 |
| Pittsburgh | 19 | 72 | L1 | .486 | 68 |
| Cincinnati | 20 | 73 | W2 | .479 | 67 |
| Tampa Bay | - | 56 | L1 | .597 | 83 |
| New York | 3.5 | 60 | W2 | .571 | 80 |
| Boston | 8.5 | 65 | L2 | .536 | 75 |
| Toronto | 14.5 | 71 | W1 | .493 | 69 |
| Baltimore | 14.5 | 71 | L2 | .493 | 69 |
How the scoring went
- 1st Inning1-0McCutchen singled to left, Horwitz scored, Reynolds to second.
- 1st Inning1-1Mountcastle hit sacrifice fly to center, Holliday scored.
- 6th Inning1-2J. Jackson homered to right (362 feet).
- 9th Inning2-2Pham homered to left center (376 feet).
- 11th Inning2-3Basallo singled to left, Henderson scored, Cowser to second, Mountcastle to third.
Win probability
Above the line favours Baltimore Orioles, below favours Pittsburgh Pirates.
Venue
- Oriole Park at Camden YardsBaltimore, Maryland
- Attendance15488
- OfficialsAlex Mackay, Alan Porter, Jim Wolf, Manny Gonzalez
Elsewhere
- 2026 MLB ABS challenge system tracker: Team, player rankings
- Saggese hits go-ahead single in the 10th in the Cardinals' 8-6 victory over the Dodgers
- St. Louis Cardinals vs. Los Angeles Dodgers: Game Highlights
- Schlittler sharp, the Yankees score 5 2-out runs in the 10th in a 6-3 win over the Angels
- New York Yankees vs. Los Angeles Angels: Game Highlights
- Pitcher Trent Thornton has fit of rage in dugout after being pulled by Cubs
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Pirates Sweep Orioles with 8-2 VictoryApr 5, 2026
- Pirates Complete Sweep Over Orioles in Close GameApr 4, 2026
- Pirates Edge Orioles in Thrilling 5-4 VictoryApr 3, 2026
- Orioles Secure Victory Over Pirates 5-2Mar 19, 2026
- Pirates Edge Orioles in High-Scoring AffairMar 14, 2026