Brewers Edge Cardinals in Thrilling Extra-Inning Showdown
Saturday, September 13, 2025, 8:15 PM ET · American Family Field
Milwaukee Brewers 9, St. Louis Cardinals 8, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won St. Louis Cardinals vs Milwaukee Brewers?
Milwaukee Brewers beat St. Louis Cardinals 9-8 at American Family Field on September 13, 2025.
In a dramatic conclusion to their series, the Milwaukee Brewers triumphed over the St. Louis Cardinals with a final score of 9-8 after ten innings. This victory not only showcased the Brewers' resilience but also solidified their dominance over the Cardinals, winning the series 5-2. The game, held at American Family Field, was marked by a series of intense scoring plays that kept fans on the edge of their seats.
The Brewers entered the game with a home record of 91-58, while the Cardinals were at 72-77 on the road. Milwaukee's recent form showed a mixed bag with a record of 5-5 over their last ten games, but they were on a one-game winning streak following a convincing 8-2 win against the Cardinals just the day before. The Brewers averaged 4.9 runs scored and allowed 4.0 runs during this stretch, indicating a balanced performance. Their last five games saw them score an average of 5.2 runs while allowing only 3.0, reflecting a slight uptick in their offensive capabilities.
In contrast, the Cardinals struggled significantly, entering the game on a four-game losing streak and holding a record of 3-7 over their last ten. They averaged only 2.9 runs scored while conceding 5.2 runs, highlighting their difficulties both offensively and defensively. Their away record was particularly concerning, as they had lost all five of their last away games.
The matchup was also notable for the injury lists on both sides. The Brewers were missing several key players, including Rob Zastryzny, Brandon Woodruff, and Quinn Priester, all on the 60-Day Injured List due to shoulder issues. Bryse Wilson was also out with a back injury on the 15-Day IL. For the Cardinals, Everson Pereira was on the 10-Day IL with a hand injury, while Ramon Urias was day-to-day with an arm issue. Masyn Winn, Andre Pallante, and JJ Wetherholt were also sidelined due to various injuries, which undoubtedly affected their performance.
The game itself was a rollercoaster of emotions. The Brewers initially fell behind, with the Cardinals leading 7-4 at one point. However, the Brewers mounted a comeback in the ninth inning, scoring three runs to tie the game at 7-7. Key plays included a double by Frelick that brought in Durbin, and an infield single by Contreras that allowed Frelick to score. The Cardinals managed to push one more run across in the tenth inning, but the Brewers responded decisively, with Monasterio's single bringing in the winning run.
The Brewers' ability to perform under pressure was evident, particularly in their late-game execution, which proved crucial in securing the win. The Cardinals, despite their struggles, showcased moments of resilience but ultimately could not maintain their lead against a determined Brewers team.
The betting market reflected the Brewers' strong position, with odds favoring them significantly, attributed to their impressive home record and recent form. The conditions at American Family Field were conducive to a competitive game, and the atmosphere was electric as fans witnessed a thrilling finish.
Viewers should have noted the Brewers' aggressive approach at the plate, particularly in high-pressure situations, as well as the Cardinals' defensive lapses that contributed to their downfall. The game was a testament to the unpredictable nature of baseball, where momentum can shift rapidly, and teams must remain vigilant until the final out.
Injury report
- Rob Zastryzny60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Bryse Wilson15-Day-ILBackMilwaukee Brewers
- Brandon Woodruff60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Quinn Priester60-Day-ILShoulderMilwaukee Brewers
- Angel Zerpa60-Day-ILElbowMilwaukee Brewers
- Everson Pereira10-Day-ILHandSt. Louis Cardinals
- Ramon UriasDay-To-DayArmSt. Louis Cardinals
- Masyn Winn10-Day-ILThumbSt. Louis Cardinals
- Andre Pallante15-Day-ILElbowSt. Louis Cardinals
- JJ Wetherholt10-Day-ILWristSt. Louis Cardinals
Recent form
Milwaukee Brewers
Last 10: 5-5Streak W14.9 scored · 4 allowed per game2-2 at home
- W8-2vs St. Louis CardinalsSep 13
- L4-5at Texas RangersSep 10
- L0-5at Texas RangersSep 9
- W10-2at Pittsburgh PiratesSep 7
- W4-1at Pittsburgh PiratesSep 6
- W5-2at Pittsburgh PiratesSep 5
- L0-2vs Philadelphia PhilliesSep 4
- W6-3vs Philadelphia PhilliesSep 3
- L8-10vs Philadelphia PhilliesSep 1
- L4-8at Toronto Blue JaysAug 31
St. Louis Cardinals
Last 10: 3-7Streak L42.9 scored · 5.2 allowed per game0-5 away
- L2-8at Milwaukee BrewersSep 13
- L2-4at Seattle MarinersSep 11
- L3-5at Seattle MarinersSep 10
- L2-4at Seattle MarinersSep 9
- W4-3vs San Francisco GiantsSep 7
- L2-8vs San Francisco GiantsSep 6
- W5-1vs AthleticsSep 3
- W2-1vs AthleticsSep 2
- L3-11vs AthleticsSep 1
- L4-7at Cincinnati RedsAug 31
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee | - | 53 | W2 | .621 | 87 |
| Chicago | 9 | 62 | L2 | .557 | 78 |
| St. Louis | 17 | 70 | W2 | .500 | 70 |
| Pittsburgh | 19 | 72 | L1 | .486 | 68 |
| Cincinnati | 20 | 73 | W2 | .479 | 67 |
How the scoring went
- 1st Inning1-0Herrera homered to left center (394 feet).
- 1st Inning2-0Nootbaar doubled to center, Contreras scored on error, Nootbaar safe at third on throwing error by shortstop Ortiz.
- 3rd Inning3-0Donovan homered to right center (396 feet).
- 3rd Inning3-1Frelick hit sacrifice fly to center, Bauers scored, Ortiz to second, Durbin to third.
- 5th Inning4-1Contreras singled to right, Herrera scored.
- 6th Inning5-1Scott II hit sacrifice fly to center, Saggese scored.
- 6th Inning6-1Pagés scored on Zastryzny wild pitch, Donovan to second on wild pitch by Zastryzny.
- 6th Inning6-1Pagés scored on Zastryzny wild pitch, Donovan to second on wild pitch by Zastryzny.
- 6th Inning6-2Contreras hit sacrifice fly to center, Frelick scored.
- 8th Inning6-3Contreras hit sacrifice fly to center, Frelick scored, Chourio to third.
- 8th Inning6-4Yelich grounded out to shortstop, Chourio scored, Turang to second.
- 9th Inning7-4Saggese singled to right, Church scored on error, Saggese safe at second on throwing error by right fielder Frelick, Contreras safe at third on error.
- 9th Inning7-5Frelick doubled to center, Durbin scored, Monasterio to third.
- 9th Inning7-6Chourio reached on infield single to second, Monasterio scored, Frelick to third.
- 9th Inning7-7Contreras reached on infield single to third, Frelick scored, Chourio to second.
- 10th Inning8-7Herrera grounded into double play, shortstop to second to first, Walker scored, Donovan out at second, Scott II to third.
- 10th Inning8-8Durbin doubled to left, Perkins scored.
- 10th Inning8-9Monasterio singled to center, Durbin scored.
Win probability
Above the line favours Milwaukee Brewers, below favours St. Louis Cardinals.
Venue
- American Family FieldMilwaukee, Wisconsin
- Attendance41807
- OfficialsChris Conroy, Brennan Miller, Jeremie Rehak, Tom Hanahan
Elsewhere
- 2026 MLB ABS challenge system tracker: Team, player rankings
- Saggese hits go-ahead single in the 10th in the Cardinals' 8-6 victory over the Dodgers
- St. Louis Cardinals vs. Los Angeles Dodgers: Game Highlights
- Schlittler sharp, the Yankees score 5 2-out runs in the 10th in a 6-3 win over the Angels
- New York Yankees vs. Los Angeles Angels: Game Highlights
- Pitcher Trent Thornton has fit of rage in dugout after being pulled by Cubs
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Brewers Complete Sweep Over Cardinals with 6-4 VictorySep 27, 2026
- Brewers Edge Cardinals in Close Contest at HomeSep 26, 2026
- Brewers Secure Victory Over Cardinals in High-Scoring AffairSep 25, 2026
- Brewers Defeat Cardinals 8-4 at Busch StadiumJul 9, 2026
- Cardinals Dominate Brewers in 5-1 VictoryJul 8, 2026