Yankees Edge Blue Jays in Thrilling Finish
Tuesday, May 19, 2026, 7:05 PM ET · Yankee Stadium
New York Yankees 5, Toronto Blue Jays 4, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees?
New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 5-4 at Yankee Stadium on May 19, 2026.
Who was favored in Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees?
New York Yankees were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -132 (about 57% implied). The favorite won.
In a tightly contested matchup, the New York Yankees triumphed over the Toronto Blue Jays with a final score of 5-4 at Yankee Stadium. This victory allowed the Yankees to take a 3-2 lead in the current series, which had been tied 2-2 prior to this game. The Yankees improved their home record to 31-19, while the Blue Jays fell to 21-28 on the season.
The Yankees entered this game with a recent record of 3-7 over their last ten games, having averaged 3.5 runs scored and 4.7 runs allowed during that stretch. Their last five games showed a slight improvement, with an average of 4.2 runs scored and 5.6 runs allowed. In contrast, the Blue Jays had a more balanced recent form, going 5-5 in their last ten games, with an average of 4.7 runs scored and 3.7 runs allowed. They had lost their previous game against the Yankees just a day earlier, which added to the competitive atmosphere.
At Yankee Stadium, the Yankees have demonstrated a strong home presence, while the Blue Jays have struggled on the road, contributing to the Yankees' overall advantage in this matchup. The last five meetings between these two teams had seen the Yankees winning three times, with the Blue Jays claiming two victories. This history set the stage for an exciting game, especially with both teams looking to gain momentum in the series.
In terms of injuries, the Yankees were dealing with several key players on the injured list, including Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Clarke Schmidt, all of whom were significant contributors to the team prior to their injuries. The Blue Jays also faced challenges, with Patrick Corbin and Anthony Santander among those sidelined. These absences undoubtedly impacted both teams' strategies and performance.
The betting market, as reported by DraftKings, had the Yankees favored at -132 on the money line, with a spread of -1.5 and a total set at 8.5 runs. The odds reflected the Yankees' stronger home record and recent performance, although the Blue Jays' recent form made them a competitive opponent.
The game unfolded with a series of scoring plays that kept fans on the edge of their seats. The Blue Jays took an early lead in the fourth inning, scoring three runs thanks to a series of singles that capitalized on the Yankees' pitching. However, the Yankees responded dramatically in the same inning when McMahon hit a three-run homer, tying the game at 3-3. The momentum shifted again in the fifth inning when Rice homered, bringing the Yankees ahead 5-3.
As the game progressed into the ninth inning, the Blue Jays managed to score another run with Guerrero Jr.'s sacrifice fly, but it wasn't enough to overcome the Yankees' lead. The final score of 5-4 highlighted the intensity and competitiveness of the matchup, showcasing the resilience of both teams.
Fans watching the game were treated to a display of power hitting and strategic plays, with key moments including the pivotal home runs and crucial defensive plays. The atmosphere at Yankee Stadium was electric, as the home crowd rallied behind their team.
Overall, this game not only provided a thrilling conclusion to the series but also highlighted the ongoing rivalry between the Yankees and Blue Jays. With both teams pushing for playoff positioning, the stakes are high as they continue to battle it out in the coming weeks.
Odds
| Book | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| DraftKings | NYY -132 | 8.5 o -121 / u +100 | Toronto Blue Jays +109 · New York Yankees -132 |
Injury report
- George Lombard Jr.Day-To-DayKneeNew York Yankees
- Aaron Judge60-Day-ILRibsNew York Yankees
- Clarke Schmidt60-Day-ILElbowNew York Yankees
- Ryan Weathers15-Day-ILForearmNew York Yankees
- Giancarlo Stanton60-Day-ILCalfNew York Yankees
- Patrick Corbin60-Day-ILShoulderToronto Blue Jays
- Jameson Taillon15-Day-ILForearmToronto Blue Jays
- Luis Urias10-Day-ILQuadricepsToronto Blue Jays
- Anthony Santander60-Day-ILShoulderToronto Blue Jays
- Jonatan Clase60-Day-ILFootToronto Blue Jays
Recent form
New York Yankees
Last 10: 3-7Streak W13.5 scored · 4.7 allowed per game1-0 at home
- W7-6vs Toronto Blue JaysMay 18
- L6-7at New York MetsMay 17
- L3-6at New York MetsMay 16
- W5-2at New York MetsMay 15
- L0-7at Baltimore OriolesMay 13
- W6-2at Baltimore OriolesMay 12
- L2-3at Baltimore OriolesMay 11
- L3-4at Milwaukee BrewersMay 10
- L3-4at Milwaukee BrewersMay 9
- L0-6at Milwaukee BrewersMay 8
Toronto Blue Jays
Last 10: 5-5Streak L14.7 scored · 3.7 allowed per game2-2 away
- L6-7at New York YankeesMay 18
- W4-1at Detroit TigersMay 17
- W2-1at Detroit TigersMay 16
- L2-3at Detroit TigersMay 15
- W5-3vs Tampa Bay RaysMay 13
- L6-7vs Tampa Bay RaysMay 12
- L5-8vs Tampa Bay RaysMay 11
- L1-6vs Los Angeles AngelsMay 10
- W14-1vs Los Angeles AngelsMay 9
- W2-0vs Los Angeles AngelsMay 8
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tampa Bay | - | 56 | L1 | .597 | 83 |
| New York | 3.5 | 60 | W2 | .571 | 80 |
| Boston | 8.5 | 65 | L2 | .536 | 75 |
| Toronto | 14.5 | 71 | W1 | .493 | 69 |
| Baltimore | 14.5 | 71 | L2 | .493 | 69 |
How the scoring went
- 4th Inning1-0Pinango singled to right, Varsho scored, Okamoto to third.
- 4th Inning2-0Sánchez singled to left, Okamoto scored, Pinango to second.
- 4th Inning3-0Giménez singled to left, Pinango scored, Sánchez to third.
- 4th Inning3-3McMahon homered to left (383 feet), Judge scored and Chisholm Jr. scored.
- 5th Inning3-5Rice homered to right center (366 feet), Grisham scored.
- 9th Inning4-5Guerrero Jr. hit sacrifice fly to center, Giménez scored.
Win probability
Above the line favours New York Yankees, below favours Toronto Blue Jays.
Venue
- Yankee StadiumBronx, New York
- Attendance37181
- OfficialsJohn Tumpane, Brock Ballou, Brennan Miller, Ben May
Elsewhere
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Yankees Secure Series Win Against Blue JaysAug 23, 2026
- Blue Jays Edge Yankees in Thrilling FinishAug 22, 2026
- Yankees Secure Series Win Over Blue JaysAug 21, 2026
- Yankees Edge Blue Jays in Extra Innings ThrillerAug 16, 2026
- Blue Jays Secure Series Win Over YankeesAug 15, 2026