Blue Jays Edge Yankees in Close Contest
Wednesday, May 20, 2026, 7:05 PM ET · Yankee Stadium
Toronto Blue Jays 2, New York Yankees 1, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees?
Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 2-1 at Yankee Stadium on May 20, 2026.
Who was favored in Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees?
New York Yankees were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -166 (about 62% implied). The underdog won.
In a tightly contested game at Yankee Stadium, the Toronto Blue Jays triumphed over the New York Yankees with a final score of 2-1. This victory marked a significant moment in the series, which is now tied 2-2. The Blue Jays, who have struggled on the road this season with a record of 22-27, managed to secure this win despite their recent form, which has seen them lose their last two games prior to this matchup.
The Yankees entered the game with a home record of 30-20 and had won their previous two encounters against the Blue Jays, including a 5-4 victory just a day prior. Over their last ten games, the Yankees have recorded a 4-6 record, with an average of 4.0 runs scored and 4.5 runs allowed per game. Their recent form shows a slight improvement, as they averaged 5.2 runs scored in their last five games, but they have faced challenges with injuries to key players.
Injuries have significantly impacted the Yankees, with several players on the injured list. Aaron Judge is currently on the 60-day injured list due to rib issues, while Giancarlo Stanton is also sidelined for 60 days with a calf injury. Other players like Clarke Schmidt and Ryan Weathers are on the 60-day and 15-day injured lists, respectively. George Lombard Jr. is listed as day-to-day with a knee issue, adding to the Yankees' challenges as they navigate through the season.
On the other hand, the Blue Jays have also been affected by injuries. Patrick Corbin is on the 60-day injured list with a shoulder injury, and Jameson Taillon is on the 15-day injured list due to a forearm issue. Luis Urias, Anthony Santander, and Jonatan Clase are also dealing with injuries, which have hindered their performance this season.
The betting market reflected the Yankees as favorites with odds of -166 from DraftKings, while the Blue Jays were set at +137. The total for the game was set at 7.5, indicating expectations for a low-scoring affair, which ultimately proved accurate given the final score.
The game's conditions were typical for a late May evening in New York, with fans braving the elements to support their teams. The atmosphere at Yankee Stadium was electric, as both teams sought to gain an advantage in this closely matched series.
Key moments in the game included a critical seventh inning where the Blue Jays scored both of their runs. Andrés Giménez walked, allowing Ernie Clement to score, followed by a sacrifice fly from Vladimir Guerrero Jr. that brought in Brandon Valenzuela. The Yankees managed to score one run in the ninth inning due to a groundout from Paul Goldschmidt, but it was not enough to overcome the Blue Jays' lead.
As the series continues, both teams will look to address their injury concerns and improve their performances. The Yankees will aim to bounce back from this loss, while the Blue Jays will seek to build on this victory and gain momentum in the series.
Odds
| Book | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| DraftKings | NYY -166 | 7.5 o -119 / u -101 | Toronto Blue Jays +137 · New York Yankees -166 |
Injury report
- George Lombard Jr.Day-To-DayKneeNew York Yankees
- Aaron Judge60-Day-ILRibsNew York Yankees
- Clarke Schmidt60-Day-ILElbowNew York Yankees
- Ryan Weathers15-Day-ILForearmNew York Yankees
- Giancarlo Stanton60-Day-ILCalfNew York Yankees
- Patrick Corbin60-Day-ILShoulderToronto Blue Jays
- Jameson Taillon15-Day-ILForearmToronto Blue Jays
- Luis Urias10-Day-ILQuadricepsToronto Blue Jays
- Anthony Santander60-Day-ILShoulderToronto Blue Jays
- Jonatan Clase60-Day-ILFootToronto Blue Jays
Recent form
New York Yankees
Last 10: 4-6Streak W24 scored · 4.5 allowed per game2-0 at home
- W5-4vs Toronto Blue JaysMay 19
- W7-6vs Toronto Blue JaysMay 18
- L6-7at New York MetsMay 17
- L3-6at New York MetsMay 16
- W5-2at New York MetsMay 15
- L0-7at Baltimore OriolesMay 13
- W6-2at Baltimore OriolesMay 12
- L2-3at Baltimore OriolesMay 11
- L3-4at Milwaukee BrewersMay 10
- L3-4at Milwaukee BrewersMay 9
Toronto Blue Jays
Last 10: 4-6Streak L24.9 scored · 4.2 allowed per game2-3 away
- L4-5at New York YankeesMay 19
- L6-7at New York YankeesMay 18
- W4-1at Detroit TigersMay 17
- W2-1at Detroit TigersMay 16
- L2-3at Detroit TigersMay 15
- W5-3vs Tampa Bay RaysMay 13
- L6-7vs Tampa Bay RaysMay 12
- L5-8vs Tampa Bay RaysMay 11
- L1-6vs Los Angeles AngelsMay 10
- W14-1vs Los Angeles AngelsMay 9
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tampa Bay | - | 56 | L1 | .597 | 83 |
| New York | 3.5 | 60 | W2 | .571 | 80 |
| Boston | 8.5 | 65 | L2 | .536 | 75 |
| Toronto | 14.5 | 71 | W1 | .493 | 69 |
| Baltimore | 14.5 | 71 | L2 | .493 | 69 |
How the scoring went
- 7th Inning1-0Austin Wells challenged (pitch result), call on the field was confirmed: Andrés Giménez walks. Ernie Clement scores. Jesús Sánchez to 3rd. Brandon Valenzuela to 2nd.
- 7th Inning2-0Guerrero Jr. hit sacrifice fly to right, Valenzuela scored, Giménez to third.
- 9th Inning2-1Goldschmidt grounded out to pitcher, Bellinger scored, Chisholm Jr. to second.
Win probability
Above the line favours New York Yankees, below favours Toronto Blue Jays.
Venue
- Yankee StadiumBronx, New York
- Attendance37497
- OfficialsBrock Ballou, Brennan Miller, Ben May, John Tumpane
Elsewhere
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Yankees Secure Series Win Against Blue JaysAug 23, 2026
- Blue Jays Edge Yankees in Thrilling FinishAug 22, 2026
- Yankees Secure Series Win Over Blue JaysAug 21, 2026
- Yankees Edge Blue Jays in Extra Innings ThrillerAug 16, 2026
- Blue Jays Secure Series Win Over YankeesAug 15, 2026