ENSign in
NHL · Final/OT

Utah Mammoth Edges Pittsburgh Penguins in OT Thriller

Sunday, December 14, 2025, 3:00 PM ET · PPG Paints Arena

Utah Mammoth 5, Pittsburgh Penguins 4, final. Our NHL picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.

Next free pick (not the main pick)

The next free pick, for your email

Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.

Unlock today's pick in Telegram →

or by email

Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick

One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.

Get the daily free pick · See plans

Quick answers

Who won Utah Mammoth vs Pittsburgh Penguins?

Utah Mammoth beat Pittsburgh Penguins 5-4 at PPG Paints Arena on December 14, 2025.

Who was favored in Utah Mammoth vs Pittsburgh Penguins?

Utah Mammoth were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -130 (about 57% implied). The favorite won.

In a thrilling contest at PPG Paints Arena, the Utah Mammoth defeated the Pittsburgh Penguins 5-4 in overtime, marking their second consecutive win against the Penguins in the current series, which they now lead 2-0. This game showcased a dramatic shift in momentum, with the Mammoth overcoming a two-goal deficit in the third period to secure the victory.

The Penguins entered the game with a home record of 14-8-9, struggling recently with a record of 4-6 in their last ten games. They have been on a four-game losing streak, averaging 3.3 goals scored and 3.6 goals allowed during this stretch. Their recent performances have raised concerns, particularly at home, where they have only won once in their last six games. In contrast, the Mammoth, with an away record of 16-15-3, have shown a mixed form, winning three of their last ten games, including their most recent victory against the Seattle Kraken.

The scoring opened in the first period with Bryan Rust netting a backhand goal, assisted by Rickard Rakell, giving the Penguins an early 2-0 lead. The Mammoth responded in the third period, starting with Nate Schmidt's goal, followed by a quick succession of goals from Michael Carcone and Sean Durzi, which shifted the momentum firmly in their favor. The Penguins managed to equalize late in the third period with a goal from Justin Brazeau, pushing the game into overtime.

In overtime, Dylan Guenther sealed the victory for the Mammoth with a wrist shot, assisted by John Marino. This win is significant for the Mammoth as they continue to build on their recent form, while the Penguins face increasing pressure to turn their season around.

In terms of injuries, the Penguins were without Caleb Jones, who is on injured reserve due to a shoulder injury. The Mammoth faced their own challenges with Barrett Hayton ruled out with an upper body injury and Caleb Desnoyers listed as day-to-day with a leg issue. The absence of key players could have impacted both teams' performances.

The betting market reflected the Mammoth's strong form heading into the game, with DraftKings listing them as -130 favorites, while the Penguins were at +110 on the money line. The spread was set at 1.5, with a total of 6.5 for the game, indicating expectations of a competitive matchup.

Conditions at PPG Paints Arena were typical for a winter evening, with fans eager to support the Penguins despite their recent struggles. The atmosphere was electric, particularly as the game progressed into overtime, with both teams vying for crucial points in the league standings.

Viewers watching the game were treated to a showcase of skill and determination, particularly in the third period and overtime, where both teams displayed resilience and offensive prowess. The Mammoth's ability to capitalize on opportunities and the Penguins' struggle to maintain their lead were key storylines in this closely contested match.

Odds

BookSpreadTotalMoneyline
DraftKingsUTAH -130 6.5 o +105 / u -125 Utah Mammoth -130 · Pittsburgh Penguins +110

What these prices pay on $100 · What these numbers mean

Injury report

  • Caleb JonesInjured ReserveShoulderPittsburgh Penguins
  • Caleb DesnoyersDay-To-DayLegUtah Mammoth
  • Barrett HaytonOutUpper BodyUtah Mammoth

Leaders

  • GoalsJustin Brazeau2Pittsburgh Penguins
  • AssistsBen Kindel2Pittsburgh Penguins
  • PointsBen Kindel3Pittsburgh Penguins
  • GoalsMichael Carcone2Utah Mammoth
  • AssistsJohn Marino1Utah Mammoth
  • PointsMichael Carcone2Utah Mammoth

Recent form

Pittsburgh Penguins

Last 10: 4-6Streak L43.3 scored · 3.6 allowed per game1-5 at home

  • L5-6vs San Jose SharksDec 13
  • L2-4vs Montreal CanadiensDec 12
  • L3-4vs Anaheim DucksDec 10
  • L2-3at Dallas StarsDec 7
  • W4-3at Tampa Bay LightningDec 5
  • W5-1at Philadelphia FlyersDec 2
  • L2-7vs Toronto Maple LeafsNov 30
  • W4-3at Columbus Blue JacketsNov 29
  • W4-2vs Buffalo SabresNov 27
  • L2-3vs Seattle KrakenNov 23

Utah Mammoth

Last 10: 3-7Streak W13 scored · 2.9 allowed per game2-4 away

  • W5-3vs Seattle KrakenDec 13
  • L3-4vs Florida PanthersDec 11
  • L2-4vs Los Angeles KingsDec 9
  • L0-2at Calgary FlamesDec 7
  • W4-1at Vancouver CanucksDec 6
  • W7-0at Anaheim DucksDec 4
  • L3-6at San Jose SharksDec 2
  • L0-1at St. Louis BluesNov 30
  • L3-4at Dallas StarsNov 29
  • L3-4vs Montreal CanadiensNov 27

Standings

TeamOt lossesLostPointsWon
Colorado111612155
Dallas122011250
Minnesota122410446
Utah6339243
St. Louis12338637
Nashville10348638
Winnipeg12358235
Chicago14397229
Carolina72211353
Pittsburgh16259841
Philadelphia12279843
Washington9309543
Columbus12309240
NY Islanders5349143
New Jersey3378742
NY Rangers9397734

Box score

StatUtah MammothPittsburgh Penguins
Blocked shots717
Hits918
Takeaways54
Shots total3616
Power play goals10
Power play opportunities52
Power play pct20.00.0
Short handed goals00
Shootout goals00
Faceoffs won3232
Faceoff percent50.050.0
Giveaways2015
Penalties25
Penalty minutes410

How the scoring went

  1. 1st0-1Justin Brazeau Goal (7) Backhand, assists: Ben Kindel (5), Rutger McGroarty (1)
  2. 1st0-2Bryan Rust Goal (11) Backhand, assists: Rickard Rakell (6)
  3. 2nd0-3Ben Kindel Goal (8) Wrist Shot, assists: Ryan Shea (10), Kris Letang (14)
  4. 3rd1-3Nate Schmidt Goal (2) Wrist Shot, assists: Nick Schmaltz (18), JJ Peterka (12)
  5. 3rd2-3Michael Carcone Goal (5) Wrist Shot, assists: none
  6. 3rd3-3Sean Durzi Goal (1) Wrist Shot, assists: Kailer Yamamoto (5), Mikhail Sergachev (18)
  7. 3rd4-3Michael Carcone Goal (6) Wrist Shot, assists: Barrett Hayton (3), Daniil But (1)
  8. 3rd4-4Justin Brazeau Goal (8) Tip-In, assists: Erik Karlsson (21), Ben Kindel (6)
  9. OT5-4Dylan Guenther Goal (15) Wrist Shot, assists: John Marino (15)

Venue

  • PPG Paints ArenaPittsburgh, PA
  • Attendance15686
  • OfficialsFrancis Charron, Carter Sandlak, Jonathan Deschamps, Shawn Oliver

Elsewhere

Picks for NHL

NHL rules and settlement

These two, other days

Every meeting

Most days: one sealed pick, free, before kick-off. Your first day of the main pick is free any day: code FIRSTDAY, no card.

A short email on days we have a pick. One click to stop, any time. 21+.

Fixture data from the league feeds. The report was written from the recorded facts for this game and nothing else.