ENSign in
MLS · FT

New York City FC Edges Columbus Crew 3-2 in Thrilling Encounter

Wednesday, September 17, 2025, 7:30 PM ET · Yankee Stadium

New York City FC 3, Columbus Crew 2, final. Our MLS picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.

Next free pick (not the main pick)

The next free pick, for your email

Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.

Unlock today's pick in Telegram →

or by email

Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick

One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.

Get the daily free pick · See plans

Quick answers

Who won Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

New York City FC beat Columbus Crew 3-2 at Yankee Stadium on September 17, 2025.

In a captivating match at Yankee Stadium, New York City FC triumphed over Columbus Crew with a score of 3-2. This victory marked a significant moment for NYCFC, as they have been striving to improve their standing in the league. The win also adds to their home record, which now stands at 15 wins, 5 draws, and 9 losses for the season.

Both teams entered the match with notable recent performances. New York City FC had a mixed bag in their last five games, recording three wins and two losses. They faced Toluca and D.C. United, suffering defeats in both matches, but rebounded with victories against Nashville SC, FC Cincinnati, and Chicago Fire FC. Their most recent match before this fixture was a convincing 3-1 win against Chicago Fire FC, showcasing their ability to score, averaging 2.2 goals in their last five home games while allowing 1.4.

Columbus Crew, on the other hand, had a more varied recent form, with two wins, two draws, and one loss in their last five outings. They secured a thrilling 5-4 victory against Atlanta United FC in their last match, which highlighted their offensive capabilities, although their defense has been somewhat leaky, averaging 1.6 goals scored and 2.0 allowed in their last five games. They also drew against Toronto FC and had a loss to New England Revolution, illustrating the inconsistency that has plagued their season.

Historically, this matchup has favored Columbus Crew, who lead the series with three wins, two draws, and no losses against NYCFC. In their last three meetings, NYCFC has struggled, with their most recent encounter ending in a 0-0 draw earlier in the 2025 season. Prior to that, they lost 2-4 and 2-3 in two encounters during the 2024 season, underscoring the challenge they faced against Columbus.

In terms of player availability, both teams were keen to field their strongest lineups. However, the block does not provide specific details on injuries, which could have influenced the match dynamics. The absence or presence of key players often plays a crucial role in such tightly contested fixtures.

The betting market had New York City FC as slight favorites, reflecting their home advantage. The odds were provided by an unnamed provider, indicating a competitive atmosphere for this encounter. The conditions at Yankee Stadium were conducive to an exciting match, with fans creating an electric atmosphere that often inspires players to perform at their best.

As the match unfolded, spectators were treated to an engaging contest. NYCFC's ability to capitalize on their home advantage was evident, as they looked to assert their dominance early on. Columbus Crew, known for their attacking prowess, aimed to exploit any defensive lapses from the home side. The tactical battle between the two coaches added another layer of intrigue, with both teams eager to secure vital points in the league standings.

Ultimately, the match showcased the resilience and determination of New York City FC, who managed to secure the win against a historically challenging opponent. The final score of 3-2 not only boosts their confidence but also serves as a reminder of their potential as they continue to navigate the remainder of the season.

Leaders

  • Total ShotsHannes Wolf5New York City FC
  • Accurate PassesThiago Martins78New York City FC
  • SavesMatt Freese3New York City FC
  • Total ShotsWessam Abou Ali3Columbus Crew
  • Accurate PassesYevhen Cheberko44Columbus Crew
  • SavesPatrick Schulte5Columbus Crew

Recent form

New York City FC

Last 10: 6-3-1Streak W11.7 scored · 1.3 allowed per game2-1 at home

  • L2-1vs TolucaAug 5
  • W2-1vs Nashville SCAug 17
  • W1-0vs FC CincinnatiAug 23
  • L2-1vs D.C. UnitedAug 30
  • W3-1vs Chicago Fire FCSep 13

Columbus Crew

Last 10: 4-3-3Streak W11.6 scored · 1.7 allowed per game2-1 away

  • W1-0vs LeónAug 5
  • D1-1vs Toronto FCAug 16
  • L2-1vs New England RevolutionAug 23
  • D0-0vs Red Bull New YorkAug 30
  • W5-4vs Atlanta United FCSep 13

Standings

TeamGames playedLostPoint differentialPointsTiedWonRankOverall
Nashville SC222+3052416116-4-2
Inter Miami CF224+1542612212-6-4
Chicago Fire FC216+1137411311-4-6
New England Revolution227+937411411-4-7
Charlotte FC227+835510510-5-7
FC Cincinnati227-2317868-7-7
New York City FC228+5287777-7-8
Red Bull New York2210-14265787-5-10
Orlando City SC2211-17254797-4-11
Toronto FC227-625105105-10-7
D.C. United227-825105115-10-7
Philadelphia Union2210-52466126-6-10
Atlanta United FC2213-132136136-3-13
CF Montréal2211-162165145-6-11
Columbus Crew2212-82055155-5-12

Box score

StatNew York City FCColumbus Crew
Fouls committed1012
Yellow cards10
Red cards00
Offsides02
Won corners73
Saves35
Possession pct56.243.8
Total shots188
Shots on target85
Shot pct0.40.6
Penalty kick goals01
Penalty kick shots01
Accurate passes462347
Total passes558437
Pass pct0.80.8
Accurate crosses63
Total crosses1713
Cross pct0.40.2
Total long balls6449
Accurate long balls2916
Longball pct0.50.3
Blocked shots63
Effective tackles78
Total tackles1517
Tackle pct0.50.5
Interceptions thrown78
Effective clearance2630
Total clearance2630

Venue

  • Yankee StadiumNew York City
  • Attendance17413
  • OfficialsSergii Boiko

Elsewhere

MLS rules and settlement

These two, other days

Every meeting

Most days: one sealed pick, free, before kick-off. Your first day of the main pick is free any day: code FIRSTDAY, no card.

A short email on days we have a pick. One click to stop, any time. 21+.

Fixture data from the league feeds. The report was written from the recorded facts for this game and nothing else.