Senators Edge Maple Leafs in Overtime Thriller
Tuesday, September 23, 2025, 7:00 PM ET · Scotiabank Arena
Ottawa Senators 3, Toronto Maple Leafs 2, final. Our NHL picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Ottawa Senators vs Toronto Maple Leafs?
Ottawa Senators beat Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at Scotiabank Arena on September 23, 2025.
In a thrilling matchup at Scotiabank Arena, the Ottawa Senators defeated the Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 in overtime. This game was particularly noteworthy as it showcased a fierce rivalry, with the Senators having previously won all three meetings in the current season against the Maple Leafs. The Senators' victory continues their dominance over Toronto, having outscored them 9-5 in those encounters.
Both teams entered the game with mixed recent form. The Maple Leafs had a record of 1-0-1 to start the season, while the Senators were 1-1-0. Toronto's recent home performance has been strong, boasting a 9-1 record over their last 10 games, with an impressive five-game winning streak. They averaged 3.2 goals scored and only 1.5 allowed during this stretch. Conversely, Ottawa's last 10 games yielded a 6-4 record, with an average of 3.2 goals scored and 2.6 allowed.
At home, the Maple Leafs have been formidable, holding a 4-0 record, while the Senators have struggled on the road, starting the season with an 0-2 record away from home. This disparity in home and away performance added an interesting layer to the matchup, as the Maple Leafs aimed to leverage their home advantage.
In terms of injuries, the Maple Leafs were significantly impacted, with key players like Auston Matthews, Max Domi, and Dakota Joshua all out. Matthews, in particular, is a notable absence as he deals with a knee injury. Zack MacEwen and Chris Tanev were also on injured reserve. The Senators faced their own injury challenges, with Artem Zub and Jake Sanderson both out, and Ridly Greig serving a suspension.
The game started with the Maple Leafs taking an early lead, thanks to a goal from Auston Matthews, assisted by Oliver Ekman-Larsson and Matias Maccelli. Bobby McMann followed up with another goal, putting Toronto ahead 2-0 by the end of the first period. However, the Senators responded in the third period with a goal from Fabian Zetterlund, narrowing the gap to 2-1. Shane Pinto then scored twice for Ottawa, including the game-winner in overtime, showcasing the Senators' resilience and ability to capitalize on their opportunities.
The market had set the odds for this matchup with the Maple Leafs favored, reflecting their strong home record and recent form. However, the Senators' previous success against Toronto likely influenced the betting landscape, as they were seen as a competitive side despite their injuries.
Conditions during the game were typical for early-season hockey, with players needing to adapt to the pace and physicality that comes with a rivalry matchup. Fans were treated to a blend of skill and intensity, with both teams displaying their strengths and weaknesses throughout the contest.
Viewers should have noted the strategic adjustments made by both coaches, particularly in how they managed their lineups given the injury concerns. The performance of goaltenders and the special teams play also became critical factors in this closely contested game.
Ultimately, the Senators' ability to come back and secure the win in overtime not only adds to their confidence but also sets the tone for their upcoming games as they look to build on this momentum.
Injury report
- Zack MacEwenInjured ReserveKneeToronto Maple Leafs
- Max DomiOutBackToronto Maple Leafs
- Dakota JoshuaOutUpper BodyToronto Maple Leafs
- Auston MatthewsOutKneeToronto Maple Leafs
- Chris TanevInjured ReserveAbdomenToronto Maple Leafs
- Ridly GreigSuspensionSuspensionOttawa Senators
- Artem ZubOutLower BodyOttawa Senators
- Jake SandersonOutConcussionOttawa Senators
Leaders
- GoalsAuston Matthews1Toronto Maple Leafs
- AssistsOliver Ekman-Larsson1Toronto Maple Leafs
- PointsAuston Matthews1Toronto Maple Leafs
- GoalsShane Pinto2Ottawa Senators
- AssistsMichael Amadio1Ottawa Senators
- PointsShane Pinto2Ottawa Senators
Recent form
Toronto Maple Leafs
Last 10: 9-1Streak W53.2 scored · 1.5 allowed per game4-0 at home
- W4-3vs Detroit Red WingsApr 17
- W4-0at Buffalo SabresApr 15
- W4-1at Carolina HurricanesApr 13
- W1-0vs Montreal CanadiensApr 12
- W4-3at Tampa Bay LightningApr 9
- L1-3at Florida PanthersApr 8
- W5-0vs Columbus Blue JacketsApr 5
- W3-2vs Florida PanthersApr 2
- W3-2at Anaheim DucksMar 31
- W3-1at Los Angeles KingsMar 29
Ottawa Senators
Last 10: 6-4Streak W13.2 scored · 2.6 allowed per game0-2 away
- W7-5vs Carolina HurricanesApr 17
- L3-4vs Chicago BlackhawksApr 15
- W4-3vs Philadelphia FlyersApr 13
- W5-2vs Montreal CanadiensApr 11
- L2-5at Columbus Blue JacketsApr 8
- W4-0vs Columbus Blue JacketsApr 6
- W3-0vs Florida PanthersApr 5
- W2-1vs Tampa Bay LightningApr 3
- L2-5vs Buffalo SabresApr 1
- L0-1at Pittsburgh PenguinsMar 30
Standings
| Team | Ot losses | Lost | Points | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buffalo | 9 | 23 | 109 | 50 |
| Tampa Bay | 6 | 26 | 106 | 50 |
| Montreal | 10 | 24 | 106 | 48 |
| Boston | 10 | 27 | 100 | 45 |
| Ottawa | 11 | 27 | 99 | 44 |
| Detroit | 10 | 31 | 92 | 41 |
| Florida | 4 | 38 | 84 | 40 |
| Toronto | 14 | 36 | 78 | 32 |
Box score
| Stat | Ottawa Senators | Toronto Maple Leafs |
|---|---|---|
| Blocked shots | 10 | 17 |
| Hits | 22 | 34 |
| Takeaways | 3 | 1 |
| Shots total | 41 | 33 |
| Power play goals | 1 | 1 |
| Power play opportunities | 3 | 5 |
| Power play pct | 33.3 | 20.0 |
| Short handed goals | 1 | 0 |
| Shootout goals | 0 | 0 |
| Faceoffs won | 25 | 32 |
| Faceoff percent | 43.9 | 56.1 |
| Giveaways | 14 | 14 |
| Penalties | 5 | 3 |
| Penalty minutes | 10 | 6 |
How the scoring went
- 1st0-1Auston Matthews Goal (1) Wrist Shot, assists: Oliver Ekman-Larsson (1), Matias Maccelli (1)
- 1st0-2Bobby McMann Goal (1) Backhand, assists: Easton Cowan (1), Matias Maccelli (2)
- 3rd1-2Fabian Zetterlund Goal (1) Wrist Shot, assists: Donovan Sebrango (2), Dylan Cozens (1)
- 3rd2-2Shane Pinto Goal (1) Wrist Shot, assists: none
- OT3-2Shane Pinto Goal (2) Wrist Shot, assists: Michael Amadio (1), Jake Sanderson (1)
Venue
- Scotiabank ArenaToronto
- Attendance15162
- OfficialsScott Cherrey, Justin Kea, Pierre Lambert, Shawn Oliver
Elsewhere
- ASU's Matthew Mayich had heat stroke, lack of oxygen to brain, lawyer says
- Blues name Thomas as captain despite last season's trade rumors
- New Jersey Devils trade for Predators forward Evangelista
- Anaheim Ducks to retire former captain Ryan Getzlaf's No. 15
- Which fantasy hockey league is right for you?
- Avs' Cale Makar embracing pressure after inking record deal
Picks for NHL
NHL rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Senators Edge Maple Leafs in Close ContestOct 3, 2026
- Maple Leafs Defeat Senators 4-2 in NHL ClashSep 23, 2026
- Maple Leafs Dominate Senators in 6-1 VictorySep 23, 2026
- Senators Defeat Maple Leafs 3-1 in NHL ClashApr 15, 2026
- Senators Defeat Maple Leafs 5-2 in Rivalry MatchupMar 21, 2026