ENSign in
MLB · Final/11

Pirates Edge Reds in Extra Innings Thriller

Wednesday, September 24, 2025, 6:40 PM ET · Great American Ball Park

Pittsburgh Pirates 4, Cincinnati Reds 3, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.

Next free pick (not the main pick)

The next free pick, for your email

Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.

Unlock today's pick in Telegram →

or by email

Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick

One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.

Get the daily free pick · See plans

Quick answers

Who won Pittsburgh Pirates vs Cincinnati Reds?

Pittsburgh Pirates beat Cincinnati Reds 4-3 at Great American Ball Park on September 24, 2025.

In a closely contested matchup at Great American Ball Park, the Pittsburgh Pirates triumphed over the Cincinnati Reds with a final score of 4-3 after 11 innings. This victory not only secured a win for the Pirates but also marked the end of the Reds' series against them, with Cincinnati winning the series 4-2.

The Reds entered this game with a home record of 80-78, having gone 6-4 in their last ten games, though they were on a one-game losing streak following a 2-4 defeat to the Pirates just a day earlier. Cincinnati had averaged 3.9 runs scored and allowed 3.6 runs in their recent stretch. Their performance at home had been solid, with a record of 4-1 in their last five games, averaging 3.4 runs scored and 2.2 runs allowed.

On the other hand, the Pirates, with a record of 69-89, were on a three-game winning streak, having won four of their last ten games. They had averaged 3.8 runs scored and 3.3 runs allowed during that span. Their away record was 2-4 in the last five games, but they were showing signs of improvement with a scoring average of 4.8 runs in their last five outings.

In terms of head-to-head matchups, the Pirates and Reds had faced each other 24 times over the past two seasons, with the Reds holding a slight edge at 13 wins to the Pirates' 11. The most recent meeting before this game saw the Reds lose to the Pirates 2-4, highlighting a competitive rivalry.

Injury concerns were significant for both teams. The Reds were missing Graham Ashcraft, who is on the 60-day injured list due to an elbow issue, and several players on the 10-day injured list, including Eugenio Suarez (personal), Ke'Bryan Hayes (groin), Spencer Steer (wrist), and Michael Toglia (shoulder). The Pirates were without Konnor Griffin (60-day IL, finger), Mitch Keller (60-day IL, arm), and Endy Rodriguez (60-day IL, hip), along with Ryan O'Hearn on the 10-day IL due to a quadriceps injury.

The game unfolded with the Pirates taking an early lead in the fourth inning when Horwitz doubled to right, allowing Reynolds to score. They extended their lead in the sixth inning with another run from Horwitz, who singled to left, bringing in Reynolds again. The Reds managed to respond in the eighth inning when Stephenson homered to left center, leveling the score at 2-2 in the ninth inning with another home run.

Extra innings saw a flurry of action, with the Pirates scoring in the tenth inning on a ground rule double from Suwinski, but the Reds equalized with a sacrifice fly from Lux, bringing the score to 3-3. However, in the 11th inning, Horwitz once again played a pivotal role, doubling to right and scoring Reynolds, sealing the game for the Pirates at 4-3.

The market had priced the Reds with a home win probability of 0.0 at the end of the game, reflecting the struggles they faced both in this match and throughout the series. The conditions at Great American Ball Park were typical for a late September evening, contributing to a charged atmosphere as both teams fought for every run.

Fans watching the game were treated to a display of resilience from the Pirates, who capitalized on their opportunities, while the Reds struggled to maintain momentum despite their late-game heroics. The matchup showcased the competitive nature of both teams as they navigated injuries and fought for pride in the season's final stretch.

Injury report

  • Graham Ashcraft60-Day-ILElbowCincinnati Reds
  • Eugenio SuarezDay-To-DayPersonalCincinnati Reds
  • Ke'Bryan Hayes10-Day-ILGroinCincinnati Reds
  • Spencer Steer10-Day-ILWristCincinnati Reds
  • Michael Toglia10-Day-ILShoulderCincinnati Reds
  • Konnor Griffin60-Day-ILFingerPittsburgh Pirates
  • Ryan O'Hearn10-Day-ILQuadricepsPittsburgh Pirates
  • Mitch Keller60-Day-ILArmPittsburgh Pirates
  • Endy Rodriguez60-Day-ILHipPittsburgh Pirates

Recent form

Cincinnati Reds

Last 10: 6-4Streak L13.9 scored · 3.6 allowed per game4-1 at home

  • L2-4vs Pittsburgh PiratesSep 23
  • W1-0vs Chicago CubsSep 21
  • W6-3vs Chicago CubsSep 20
  • W7-4vs Chicago CubsSep 19
  • W1-0vs Chicago CubsSep 18
  • W6-2at St. Louis CardinalsSep 17
  • L0-3at St. Louis CardinalsSep 16
  • W11-6at St. Louis CardinalsSep 15
  • L5-11at AthleticsSep 14
  • L0-3at AthleticsSep 13

Pittsburgh Pirates

Last 10: 4-6Streak W33.8 scored · 3.3 allowed per game2-2 away

  • W4-2at Cincinnati RedsSep 23
  • W11-0vs AthleticsSep 21
  • W2-0vs AthleticsSep 20
  • L3-4vs AthleticsSep 19
  • L4-8vs Chicago CubsSep 17
  • L1-4vs Chicago CubsSep 16
  • L0-4vs Chicago CubsSep 15
  • L3-4at Washington NationalsSep 14
  • W5-1at Washington NationalsSep 13
  • L5-6at Washington NationalsSep 12

Standings

TeamGames behindLostStreakWin %Won
Milwaukee-53W2.62187
Chicago962L2.55778
St. Louis1770W2.50070
Pittsburgh1972L1.48668
Cincinnati2073W2.47967

How the scoring went

  1. 4th Inning1-0Horwitz doubled to right, Reynolds scored, Horwitz thrown out at third.
  2. 6th Inning2-0Horwitz singled to left, Reynolds scored, Horwitz to second.
  3. 8th Inning2-1Marte homered to left (408 feet).
  4. 9th Inning2-2Stephenson homered to left center (405 feet).
  5. 10th Inning3-2Suwinski hit a ground rule double, Yorke scored.
  6. 10th Inning3-3Lux hit sacrifice fly to center, Friedl scored.
  7. 11th Inning4-3Horwitz doubled to right, Reynolds scored.

Win probability

Above the line favours Cincinnati Reds, below favours Pittsburgh Pirates.

Venue

  • Great American Ball ParkCincinnati, Ohio
  • Attendance30725
  • OfficialsAdrian Johnson, Quinn Wolcott, Edwin Jimenez, Ramon De Jesus

Elsewhere

Picks for MLB

MLB rules and settlement

These two, other days

Every meeting

Most days: one sealed pick, free, before kick-off. Your first day of the main pick is free any day: code FIRSTDAY, no card.

A short email on days we have a pick. One click to stop, any time. 21+.

Fixture data from the league feeds. The report was written from the recorded facts for this game and nothing else.