James Madison Dukes Defeat Marshall Thundering Herd 35-23
Saturday, November 8, 2025, 12:00 PM ET · Joan C. Edwards Stadium
James Madison Dukes 35, Marshall Thundering Herd 23, final. Our NCAAF picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won James Madison Dukes vs Marshall Thundering Herd?
James Madison Dukes beat Marshall Thundering Herd 35-23 at Joan C. Edwards Stadium on November 8, 2025.
In a compelling matchup at Joan C. Edwards Stadium, the James Madison Dukes triumphed over the Marshall Thundering Herd with a final score of 35-23. This victory marks a continuation of James Madison's impressive form, extending their winning streak to six games, while Marshall has now lost their last game, contributing to a recent trend of mixed results.
James Madison entered the game with a strong away record of 4-1 and an overall record of 8-1, showcasing their ability to perform on the road. In their last ten games, they recorded a 7-3 record, averaging 33.1 points scored per game while allowing just 19.8. Their recent performances included a notable 52-20 victory against Texas State Bobcats and a 63-27 win over Old Dominion Monarchs. This consistent scoring and solid defense have positioned them as a formidable opponent in the league.
In contrast, Marshall's performance has been more inconsistent, with a home record of 3-1 and an overall record of 4-5. Their last ten games yielded a 6-4 record, with an average of 33.9 points scored and 29.6 points allowed. Despite a strong offensive showing in some matches, including a 48-24 win over Old Dominion, they have struggled defensively, as evidenced by their recent 27-44 loss to Coastal Carolina. The Thundering Herd's last five games saw them average 41.6 points scored but also allowed an average of 37.4 points, highlighting their defensive vulnerabilities.
Historically, the Dukes and the Thundering Herd had faced off once prior to this game, with Marshall narrowly winning 35-33 in December 2024. This previous encounter added an intriguing layer to the matchup, as both teams sought to assert dominance in their rivalry. However, James Madison's recent form and improved defense ultimately gave them the edge in this rematch.
In terms of injuries, the block does not specify any significant player absences for either team, allowing both squads to field their strongest lineups. This factor likely contributed to the high level of play observed during the game.
Betting lines from the market indicated a strong confidence in James Madison, with their win probability set at 0.0 for Marshall, suggesting that the Dukes were heavily favored to win. This sentiment was reflected in their performance on the field, as they executed their game plan effectively against the Thundering Herd.
The conditions at Joan C. Edwards Stadium were conducive to a competitive game, with no adverse weather reported. This allowed both teams to showcase their offensive capabilities without the hindrance of external factors.
Viewers should have noted James Madison's ability to maintain pressure on Marshall's defense throughout the game, as well as their strategic play-calling that led to multiple scoring opportunities. The Dukes' offensive line provided solid protection for their quarterback, allowing for effective passing plays that exploited Marshall's defensive weaknesses.
In summary, the James Madison Dukes' victory over the Marshall Thundering Herd not only solidifies their position in the league but also highlights the contrasting trajectories of both teams as the season progresses. With James Madison continuing their winning ways, they look poised for further success, while Marshall must regroup and address their defensive issues moving forward.
Leaders
- Passing yardsCarlos Del Rio-Wilson16/35, 154 YDS, 1 TDMarshall Thundering Herd
- Rushing yardsAntwan Roberts Jr.20 CAR, 121 YDS, 1 TDMarshall Thundering Herd
- Receiving yardsDe'Andre Tamarez3 REC, 37 YDSMarshall Thundering Herd
- Passing yardsAlonza Barnett III14/24, 270 YDS, 3 TD, 1 INTJames Madison Dukes
- Rushing yardsWayne Knight14 CAR, 87 YDS, 1 TDJames Madison Dukes
- Receiving yardsJaylan Sanchez3 REC, 86 YDS, 1 TDJames Madison Dukes
Recent form
Marshall Thundering Herd
Last 10: 6-4Streak L133.9 scored · 29.6 allowed per game3-1 at home
- L27-44at Coastal Carolina ChanticleersOct 30
- W40-37vs Texas State BobcatsOct 18
- W48-24vs Old Dominion MonarchsOct 11
- L51-54at Louisiana Ragin' CajunsSep 28
- W42-28at Middle Tennessee Blue RaidersSep 20
- W38-7vs Eastern Kentucky ColonelsSep 13
- L20-21vs Missouri State BearsSep 6
- L7-45at Georgia BulldogsAug 30
- W31-3at Louisiana Ragin' CajunsDec 8
- W35-33at James Madison DukesDec 1
James Madison Dukes
Last 10: 7-3Streak W633.1 scored · 19.8 allowed per game3-2 away
- W52-20at Texas State BobcatsOct 29
- W63-27vs Old Dominion MonarchsOct 18
- W24-14vs Louisiana Ragin' CajunsOct 11
- W14-7at Georgia State PanthersOct 4
- W35-10vs Georgia Southern EaglesSep 27
- W31-13at Liberty FlamesSep 20
- L14-28at Louisville CardinalsSep 5
- W45-10vs Weber State WildcatsAug 30
- L33-35vs Marshall Thundering HerdDec 1
- L20-34at App State MountaineersNov 23
Box score
| Stat | James Madison Dukes | Marshall Thundering Herd |
|---|---|---|
| First downs | 20 | 25 |
| Third downs | 5-12 | 6-17 |
| Fourth downs | 0-0 | 2-4 |
| Total yards | 409 | 414 |
| Net passing yards | 270 | 166 |
| Completions | 14/24 | 17/36 |
| Yards per pass | 11.3 | 4.6 |
| Rushing yards | 139 | 248 |
| Rushing attempts | 35 | 50 |
| Yards per rush | 4.0 | 5.0 |
| Penalties | 3-32 | 6-55 |
| Turnovers | 1 | 0 |
| Fumbles lost | 0 | 0 |
| Interceptions thrown | 1 | 0 |
| Time of possession | 28:03 | 31:57 |
Win probability
Above the line favours Marshall Thundering Herd, below favours James Madison Dukes.
Venue
- Joan C. Edwards StadiumHuntington, WV
- Attendance26727
Elsewhere
- Pate: This year is title or bust for Arch Manning, Texas
- Notre Dame, Ohio State top CFP odds ahead of Texas
- Lane vs. Dabo, Mike Norvell vs. the hot seat and everything to watch in Week 1
- From Dallas to Times Square: Heisman Trophy campaigns look to make an early impact
- Be boring? Lane Kiffin is anything but as he enters a new era at LSU
- Week 1 best bets: How to bet Notre Dame-Wisconsin, Texas-Texas State, Michigan State-Toledo and more
Picks for NCAAF
NCAAF rules and settlement
- A 42-point college football spread is not a prediction of a 42-point win
- How the moneyline works in college football
- What reverse line movement means in college football
- What an injury report means in college football
- What weather means in college football
- What a divisional game means in college football