ENSign in
NHL · Final

Islanders Defeat Maple Leafs 4-1 in NHL Clash

Saturday, October 17, 2026, 7:00 PM ET · Scotiabank Arena

New York Islanders 4, Toronto Maple Leafs 1, final. Our NHL picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.

Next free pick (not the main pick)

The next free pick, for your email

Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.

Unlock today's pick in Telegram →

or by email

Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick

One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.

Get the daily free pick · See plans

Quick answers

Who won New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs?

New York Islanders beat Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 at Scotiabank Arena on October 17, 2026.

Who was favored in New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs?

Toronto Maple Leafs were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -130 (about 57% implied). The underdog won.

In a decisive matchup at Scotiabank Arena, the New York Islanders triumphed over the Toronto Maple Leafs with a score of 4-1. This victory marked the Islanders' second consecutive win against the Maple Leafs this season, as they previously faced each other on September 30, where Toronto secured a 2-1 win. The series is now tied at 1-1 for the season.

The game began with Anthony Duclair opening the scoring for the Islanders in the first period with a wrist shot, assisted by Jean-Gabriel Pageau. The second period saw Bo Horvat extend the Islanders' lead with another wrist shot, assisted by Kyle Palmieri. In the third period, Colton Sissons scored for the Maple Leafs, but the Islanders responded with two more goals from Simon Holmstrom, who scored his second and third of the season, sealing the game at 4-1.

Both teams entered this game struggling for form. The Maple Leafs have a home record of 3-4-2, with their last ten games yielding a record of 3-7. They have been on a two-game losing streak, averaging 3.4 goals scored and 3.7 goals allowed per game during this stretch. Their recent games include a 4-5 loss to the Buffalo Sabres and a 4-5 loss to the Utah Mammoth. The Maple Leafs have struggled particularly at home, where they have a record of 2-4 in their last six home games.

On the other hand, the Islanders have an away record of 4-3-1 and a similar overall record of 3-7 in their last ten games. They are currently on a one-game losing streak, averaging 2.2 goals scored and 2.6 goals allowed over their last ten games. Their most recent outing ended in a 1-2 loss against the Ottawa Senators. The Islanders have also faced difficulties on the road, with a record of 0-3 in their last three away games.

In terms of injuries, the Maple Leafs are missing key players, including John Tavares, Dakota Joshua, Miles Wood, Chris Tanev, and Max Domi, all of whom are on injured reserve. The Islanders are dealing with the absence of Mathew Barzal, who is on injured reserve due to a knee injury, and Alexander Romanov, who is out with a knee issue. Additionally, Calum Ritchie and Matias Maccelli are listed as day-to-day with lower body injuries.

The betting market for this game, as provided by DraftKings, had the Maple Leafs as the favorites at -130 on the money line, with a spread of -1.5 and a total set at 6.5. The odds for the over were at 105.0, while the under was priced at -125. This reflects the uncertainty surrounding both teams' recent performances and the potential for scoring given their average goals per game.

The conditions for the game were typical for a hockey match in mid-October, with players needing to adapt to the early season pace and intensity. Fans watching were advised to keep an eye on the performance of the Islanders' Bo Horvat, who had a strong game with a goal and an assist, as well as Simon Holmstrom, who scored twice in the third period to help secure the win.

Overall, the Islanders' victory over the Maple Leafs showcased their ability to capitalize on scoring opportunities while exposing Toronto's defensive vulnerabilities. As the season progresses, both teams will need to address their inconsistencies to improve their standings in the league.

What we said beforehand

The Toronto Maple Leafs will face off against the New York Islanders at Scotiabank Arena on October 17, 2026, in a matchup that promises to be intriguing given both teams' recent performances and injury woes. The Maple Leafs currently lead the series 1-0, having secured a victory over the Islanders earlier in the season with a score of 2-1 on September 30, 2026.

In their last five games, the Maple Leafs have experienced a mix of highs and lows, recording two wins and three losses. Their most recent outing ended in a 5-4 overtime loss to the Buffalo Sabres on October 15, 2026. Prior to that, they defeated the Colorado Avalanche 6-3 on October 10, 2026. Overall, Toronto holds a record of 3-3-2 this season, with an average of 4.4 goals scored and 4.2 goals allowed in their last five matches. However, their home record is less impressive at 2-4, and they are currently on a two-game losing streak at home.

The Islanders, on the other hand, have also struggled, posting a record of 3-3-1. Their last five games include two wins and three losses, with their most recent match resulting in a 2-1 loss to the Ottawa Senators on October 15, 2026. The Islanders have averaged 2.6 goals scored and 3.0 goals allowed in their last five games. Their away record stands at 0-3, indicating they have yet to secure a victory on the road this season.

In terms of injuries, the Maple Leafs will be without key players including John Tavares, Dakota Joshua, Miles Wood, Chris Tanev, and Max Domi, all of whom are on injured reserve. The Islanders will miss Mathew Barzal, who is also on injured reserve due to a knee injury, while Alexander Romanov is listed as out for the game.

The betting odds from DraftKings indicate that the Maple Leafs are favored at -135, with a spread of -1.5 and a total set at 6.5. The odds for the over are at 105.0, while the under is priced at -125. The Islanders are listed at +114 on the moneyline.

As the game approaches, viewers should watch for Auston Matthews, who leads the Maple Leafs with 6 goals and 7 assists this season, totaling 13 points. For the Islanders, Bo Horvat is the leading scorer with 4 goals and 3 assists, totaling 7 points. The matchup will be crucial for both teams as they look to improve their standings and overcome recent struggles.

Odds

BookSpreadTotalMoneyline
DraftKingsTOR -130 6.5 o +105 / u -125 New York Islanders +110 · Toronto Maple Leafs -130

What these prices pay on $100 · What these numbers mean

Injury report

  • John TavaresInjured ReserveLower BodyToronto Maple Leafs
  • Dakota JoshuaInjured ReserveAbdomenToronto Maple Leafs
  • Miles WoodInjured ReserveUndisclosedToronto Maple Leafs
  • Chris TanevInjured ReserveUpper BodyToronto Maple Leafs
  • Max DomiInjured ReserveBackToronto Maple Leafs
  • Calum RitchieDay-To-DayLower BodyNew York Islanders
  • Matias MaccelliDay-To-DayLower BodyNew York Islanders
  • Mathew BarzalInjured ReserveKneeNew York Islanders
  • Alexander RomanovOutKneeNew York Islanders

Leaders

  • GoalsColton Sissons1Toronto Maple Leafs
  • AssistsTroy Stecher1Toronto Maple Leafs
  • PointsColton Sissons1Toronto Maple Leafs
  • GoalsSimon Holmstrom2New York Islanders
  • AssistsBo Horvat1New York Islanders
  • PointsSimon Holmstrom2New York Islanders

Recent form

Toronto Maple Leafs

Last 10: 3-7Streak L23.4 scored · 3.7 allowed per game2-4 at home

  • L4-5vs Buffalo SabresOct 15
  • L4-5at Utah MammothOct 14
  • W6-3at Colorado AvalancheOct 10
  • L3-4at Vegas Golden KnightsOct 9
  • W5-4vs Nashville PredatorsOct 6
  • L2-3vs Ottawa SenatorsOct 3
  • W2-1vs New York IslandersSep 30
  • L2-3vs Montreal CanadiensSep 29
  • L1-3at Ottawa SenatorsApr 15
  • L5-6vs Dallas StarsApr 13

New York Islanders

Last 10: 3-7Streak L12.2 scored · 2.6 allowed per game0-3 away

  • L1-2at Ottawa SenatorsOct 15
  • W3-2vs Vancouver CanucksOct 13
  • L3-5vs Tampa Bay LightningOct 10
  • W4-1vs Chicago BlackhawksOct 8
  • L2-5at New York RangersOct 6
  • W6-0vs New Jersey DevilsOct 3
  • L1-2at Toronto Maple LeafsSep 30
  • L1-2vs Carolina HurricanesApr 14
  • L1-4vs Montreal CanadiensApr 12
  • L0-3vs Ottawa SenatorsApr 11

Standings

TeamOt lossesLostPointsWon
Carolina11157
NY Rangers03126
Washington03105
NY Islanders1394
New Jersey0484
Pittsburgh1473
Philadelphia3651
Columbus0342
Boston02126
Tampa Bay02126
Ottawa03126
Florida22125
Buffalo23104
Montreal1394
Detroit2383
Toronto2483

Box score

StatNew York IslandersToronto Maple Leafs
Blocked shots418
Hits2918
Takeaways33
Shots total2029
Power play goals00
Power play opportunities23
Power play pct0.00.0
Short handed goals00
Shootout goals00
Faceoffs won2223
Faceoff percent48.951.1
Giveaways1519
Penalties32
Penalty minutes64

How the scoring went

  1. 1st1-0Anthony Duclair Goal (2) Wrist Shot, assists: Jean-Gabriel Pageau (3)
  2. 2nd2-0Bo Horvat Goal (5) Wrist Shot, assists: Kyle Palmieri (1)
  3. 3rd2-1Colton Sissons Goal (2) Tip-In, assists: Troy Stecher (1), Easton Cowan (4)
  4. 3rd3-1Simon Holmstrom Goal (2) Wrist Shot, assists: Bo Horvat (4), Matthew Schaefer (7)
  5. 3rd4-1Simon Holmstrom Goal (3) Wrist Shot, assists: none

Venue

  • Scotiabank ArenaToronto
  • Attendance18915
  • OfficialsMark Shewchyk, Shandor Alphonso, Pierre Lambert, Mike Sullivan

Elsewhere

Picks for NHL

NHL rules and settlement

These two, other days

Every meeting

Most days: one sealed pick, free, before kick-off. Your first day of the main pick is free any day: code FIRSTDAY, no card.

A short email on days we have a pick. One click to stop, any time. 21+.

Fixture data from the league feeds. The report was written from the recorded facts for this game and nothing else.