ENSign in
NHL · Final

Islanders Defeat Maple Leafs 5-3 in Thrilling Matchup

Thursday, April 9, 2026, 6:45 PM ET · UBS Arena

New York Islanders 5, Toronto Maple Leafs 3, final. Our NHL picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.

Next free pick (not the main pick)

The next free pick, for your email

Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.

Unlock today's pick in Telegram →

or by email

Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick

One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.

Get the daily free pick · See plans

Quick answers

Who won Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders?

New York Islanders beat Toronto Maple Leafs 5-3 at UBS Arena on April 9, 2026.

Who was favored in Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders?

New York Islanders were the favorite at DraftKings, moneyline -305 (about 75% implied). The favorite won.

The New York Islanders secured a decisive 5-3 victory over the Toronto Maple Leafs at UBS Arena, completing a dominant series sweep with a 3-0 record against their opponents this season. This matchup was particularly significant as it showcased the Islanders' ability to capitalize on their home ice advantage, improving their overall home record to 44-31-5.

In the lead-up to the game, both teams had been struggling with their recent form. The Islanders entered the contest with a record of 3-7 in their last ten games, having lost their last four, averaging 2.6 goals scored while allowing 3.7. Their recent performances included a tough loss to the Carolina Hurricanes (3-4) and a heavy defeat against the Pittsburgh Penguins (3-8). Conversely, the Maple Leafs also faced challenges, holding a 3-7 record in their last ten games and on a three-game losing streak, averaging 2.7 goals scored and 4.1 allowed. Their most recent outing ended in a 0-4 defeat against the Washington Capitals.

The game began with the Islanders taking an early lead. Brayden Schenn opened the scoring for New York with a snap shot, assisted by Calum Ritchie and Bo Horvat. Jean-Gabriel Pageau followed suit, doubling the lead with another snap shot. However, the Maple Leafs responded with a goal from Steven Lorentz, narrowing the gap to 2-1 by the end of the first period.

The second period saw a flurry of action, with Easton Cowan leveling the score for Toronto with a wrist shot. The Islanders quickly regained the lead through Matthew Schaefer, who scored with another wrist shot. Emil Heineman extended the Islanders' lead to 4-2 before the period concluded. The home team showcased their offensive prowess, capitalizing on their chances effectively.

In the third period, Calum Ritchie scored the Islanders' fifth goal, further solidifying their lead. Despite a late effort from Morgan Rielly, who scored for Toronto, the Maple Leafs could not close the gap, resulting in a final score of 5-3.

In terms of injuries, the Maple Leafs were significantly impacted, missing key players including Zack MacEwen, Max Domi, Dakota Joshua, Auston Matthews, and Chris Tanev. This injury list has undoubtedly affected their performance throughout the season, particularly in crucial matchups like this one.

The betting market reflected the Islanders' strong position heading into the game, with DraftKings listing them at -305 on the money line, while the Maple Leafs were set at +245. The spread was established at -1.5 for the Islanders, with a total of 6.5 goals, indicating expectations for a competitive game.

Overall, the Islanders demonstrated their capability to perform under pressure, especially at home, while the Maple Leafs continue to struggle with consistency and injuries. The match highlighted the Islanders' offensive strength and resilience, setting the stage for their upcoming challenges as they look to build on this victory.

Odds

BookSpreadTotalMoneyline
DraftKingsNYI -305 6.5 o -105 / u -115 Toronto Maple Leafs +245 · New York Islanders -305

What these prices pay on $100 · What these numbers mean

Injury report

  • Zack MacEwenInjured ReserveKneeToronto Maple Leafs
  • Max DomiOutBackToronto Maple Leafs
  • Dakota JoshuaOutUpper BodyToronto Maple Leafs
  • Auston MatthewsOutKneeToronto Maple Leafs
  • Chris TanevInjured ReserveAbdomenToronto Maple Leafs

Leaders

  • GoalsCalum Ritchie1New York Islanders
  • AssistsTony DeAngelo2New York Islanders
  • PointsCalum Ritchie2New York Islanders
  • GoalsMorgan Rielly1Toronto Maple Leafs
  • AssistsLuke Haymes1Toronto Maple Leafs
  • PointsMorgan Rielly1Toronto Maple Leafs

Recent form

New York Islanders

Last 10: 3-7Streak L42.6 scored · 3.7 allowed per game3-3 at home

  • L3-4at Carolina HurricanesApr 4
  • L1-4vs Philadelphia FlyersApr 3
  • L3-4at Buffalo SabresMar 31
  • L3-8vs Pittsburgh PenguinsMar 30
  • W5-2vs Florida PanthersMar 28
  • W2-1vs Dallas StarsMar 26
  • L3-4vs Chicago BlackhawksMar 24
  • W1-0vs Columbus Blue JacketsMar 22
  • L3-7at Montreal CanadiensMar 21
  • L2-3at Ottawa SenatorsMar 19

Toronto Maple Leafs

Last 10: 3-7Streak L32.7 scored · 4.1 allowed per game2-4 away

  • L0-4vs Washington CapitalsApr 8
  • L6-7at Los Angeles KingsApr 4
  • L1-4at San Jose SharksApr 3
  • W5-4at Anaheim DucksMar 31
  • L1-5at St. Louis BluesMar 28
  • W4-3vs New York RangersMar 25
  • W4-2at Boston BruinsMar 24
  • L2-5at Ottawa SenatorsMar 21
  • L3-4vs Carolina HurricanesMar 20
  • L1-3vs New York IslandersMar 17

Standings

TeamOt lossesLostPointsWon
Buffalo92310950
Tampa Bay62610650
Montreal102410648
Boston102710045
Ottawa11279944
Detroit10319241
Florida4388440
Toronto14367832
Carolina72211353
Pittsburgh16259841
Philadelphia12279843
Washington9309543
Columbus12309240
NY Islanders5349143
New Jersey3378742
NY Rangers9397734

Box score

StatToronto Maple LeafsNew York Islanders
Blocked shots1311
Hits2124
Takeaways33
Shots total1644
Power play goals12
Power play opportunities15
Power play pct100.040.0
Short handed goals00
Shootout goals00
Faceoffs won3136
Faceoff percent46.353.7
Giveaways1216
Penalties61
Penalty minutes202

How the scoring went

  1. 1st0-1Brayden Schenn Goal (18) Snap Shot, assists: Calum Ritchie (17), Bo Horvat (26)
  2. 1st0-2Jean-Gabriel Pageau Goal (17) Snap Shot, assists: Max Shabanov (13), Adam Pelech (12)
  3. 1st1-2Steven Lorentz Goal (7) Wrist Shot, assists: none
  4. 2nd2-2Easton Cowan Goal (11) Wrist Shot, assists: John Tavares (39), Oliver Ekman-Larsson (31)
  5. 2nd2-3Matthew Schaefer Goal (23) Wrist Shot, assists: Tony DeAngelo (29), Ondrej Palat (10)
  6. 2nd2-4Emil Heineman Goal (22) Snap Shot, assists: Mathew Barzal (52), Tony DeAngelo (30)
  7. 3rd2-5Calum Ritchie Goal (13) Snap Shot, assists: none
  8. 3rd3-5Morgan Rielly Goal (11) Wrist Shot, assists: Matias Maccelli (25), Luke Haymes (1)

Venue

  • UBS ArenaElmont, NY
  • Attendance17255
  • OfficialsDan Kelly, Francois St. Laurent, Furman South, Kilian McNamara

Elsewhere

Picks for NHL

NHL rules and settlement

These two, other days

Every meeting

Most days: one sealed pick, free, before kick-off. Your first day of the main pick is free any day: code FIRSTDAY, no card.

A short email on days we have a pick. One click to stop, any time. 21+.

Fixture data from the league feeds. The report was written from the recorded facts for this game and nothing else.