Cardinals Edge Pirates in Extra-Inning Thriller
Tuesday, May 19, 2026, 7:45 PM ET · Busch Stadium
St. Louis Cardinals 9, Pittsburgh Pirates 6, final. Our MLB picks are sealed as a hash before kickoff and settled in public, losses included.
The next free pick, for your email
Team, bet, price and the hash it was sealed under, on this page the moment you send. Lose or win, it stays public.
or by email
Public record of the main pick, losses included: 115 won, 44 lost. See every pick
One free pick a day by email until you unsubscribe, in one click. 21+.
Quick answers
Who won Pittsburgh Pirates vs St. Louis Cardinals?
St. Louis Cardinals beat Pittsburgh Pirates 9-6 at Busch Stadium on May 19, 2026.
In a thrilling contest that went into extra innings, the St. Louis Cardinals triumphed over the Pittsburgh Pirates with a final score of 9-6 at Busch Stadium. This victory not only secured a win for the Cardinals but also marked the end of a series in which the Pirates had previously claimed two out of three games, winning the series 2-1.
The Cardinals entered this game with a home record of 28-19, while the Pirates had a slightly less impressive away record of 24-24. Recent form for the Cardinals showed a mixed bag, with a record of 5-4-1 in their last ten games, including a streak of one loss. They averaged 3.1 runs scored per game while allowing 2.9 runs. In their last five games, their record dipped to 2-3, with an average of 3.0 runs scored and 3.8 runs allowed. Conversely, the Pirates had a record of 4-6 in their last ten games, currently on a three-game losing streak, averaging 3.9 runs scored and allowing 5.3 runs.
In terms of home and away performance, the Cardinals have demonstrated solid play at Busch Stadium, with a home record of 2-2 in their last four games. The Pirates, however, have struggled on the road, posting a 2-4 record in their last six away games.
Historically, the Cardinals have had the upper hand in their recent matchups against the Pirates, holding a 10-7 record in their last meetings. This season alone, the teams faced off three times prior to this game, with the Pirates winning all three encounters, including a notable 10-5 victory on April 30, 2026.
Injury concerns for the Cardinals included Everson Pereira and Masyn Winn, both on the 10-Day Injured List, while Ramon Urias, Andre Pallante, and JJ Wetherholt were listed as Day-To-Day. The Pirates faced their own injury issues, with Konnor Griffin on the 60-Day Injured List and Ryan O'Hearn on the 10-Day Injured List, alongside Mitch Keller and Endy Rodriguez also sidelined.
The betting lines provided by DraftKings indicated a competitive matchup, with the Cardinals at -110 on the money line and a spread of 1.5. The total for the game was set at 8.0, with the over at -111 and the under at -109, suggesting a closely contested game was anticipated.
Conditions at Busch Stadium were conducive for baseball, with fans treated to an exciting atmosphere as both teams battled for supremacy. The game featured several key scoring plays, including a wild pitch by Liberatore that allowed Lowe to score in the fifth inning, followed by a double from Reynolds that brought in two more runs for the Pirates. However, the Cardinals responded with a homer from Gorman in the sixth inning, regaining the lead.
As the game progressed into the ninth inning, the tension escalated when the Pirates tied the game at 6-6, pushing the contest into extra innings. Ultimately, the Cardinals seized the moment in the tenth inning, with Herrera hitting a crucial homer that brought in two more runs, solidifying their victory.
This game showcased the resilience of the Cardinals, who despite their recent struggles, managed to pull off a win in a high-pressure situation. Fans and analysts alike will be keen to see how both teams respond in their upcoming fixtures as the season progresses.
Odds
| Book | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| DraftKings | STL -110 | 8 o -111 / u -109 | Pittsburgh Pirates -110 · St. Louis Cardinals -110 |
Injury report
- Everson Pereira10-Day-ILHandSt. Louis Cardinals
- Ramon UriasDay-To-DayArmSt. Louis Cardinals
- Masyn Winn10-Day-ILThumbSt. Louis Cardinals
- Andre Pallante15-Day-ILElbowSt. Louis Cardinals
- JJ Wetherholt10-Day-ILWristSt. Louis Cardinals
- Konnor Griffin60-Day-ILFingerPittsburgh Pirates
- Ryan O'Hearn10-Day-ILQuadricepsPittsburgh Pirates
- Mitch Keller60-Day-ILArmPittsburgh Pirates
- Endy Rodriguez60-Day-ILHipPittsburgh Pirates
Recent form
St. Louis Cardinals
Last 10: 5-4-1Streak L13.1 scored · 2.9 allowed per game2-2 at home
- L0-2vs Kansas City RoyalsMay 17
- W5-4vs Kansas City RoyalsMay 16
- L2-6at AthleticsMay 14
- W6-4at AthleticsMay 13
- L2-3at San Diego PadresMay 10
- W6-0at San Diego PadresMay 9
- W2-1at San Diego PadresMay 8
- L2-6vs Milwaukee BrewersMay 6
- D0-0vs Milwaukee BrewersMay 5
- W6-3vs Milwaukee BrewersMay 4
Pittsburgh Pirates
Last 10: 4-6Streak L33.9 scored · 5.3 allowed per game2-2 away
- L0-6vs Philadelphia PhilliesMay 17
- L0-6vs Philadelphia PhilliesMay 16
- L9-11vs Philadelphia PhilliesMay 15
- W7-2vs Colorado RockiesMay 14
- L4-10vs Colorado RockiesMay 13
- W3-1vs Colorado RockiesMay 12
- W13-3at San Francisco GiantsMay 10
- L2-5at San Francisco GiantsMay 9
- W1-0at Arizona DiamondbacksMay 7
- L0-9at Arizona DiamondbacksMay 6
Standings
| Team | Games behind | Lost | Streak | Win % | Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee | - | 53 | W2 | .621 | 87 |
| Chicago | 9 | 62 | L2 | .557 | 78 |
| St. Louis | 17 | 70 | W2 | .500 | 70 |
| Pittsburgh | 19 | 72 | L1 | .486 | 68 |
| Cincinnati | 20 | 73 | W2 | .479 | 67 |
How the scoring went
- 3rd Inning0-2Wetherholt homered to center (406 feet), Pagés scored.
- 4th Inning0-3Gorman grounded into double play, second to shortstop to first, Burleson scored, Walker out at second.
- 5th Inning1-3Lowe scored on Liberatore wild pitch, Triolo to third on wild pitch by Liberatore.
- 5th Inning1-3Lowe scored on Liberatore wild pitch, Triolo to third on wild pitch by Liberatore.
- 5th Inning3-3Reynolds doubled to left, Gonzales scored and Triolo scored.
- 5th Inning4-3Cruz singled to right, Reynolds scored, Cruz to second, Ozuna to third.
- 6th Inning4-5Gorman homered to center (437 feet), Burleson scored.
- 8th Inning4-6Burleson homered to right center (404 feet).
- 9th Inning5-6Ozuna grounded into double play, shortstop to second to first, Gonzales scored, Reynolds out at second, Griffin to third.
- 9th Inning6-6Horwitz singled to left, Griffin scored, Cruz to second.
- 10th Inning6-9Herrera homered to left center (410 feet), Scott II scored and Wetherholt scored.
Win probability
Above the line favours St. Louis Cardinals, below favours Pittsburgh Pirates.
Venue
- Busch StadiumSt. Louis, Missouri
- Attendance22958
- OfficialsD.J. Reyburn, John Libka, James Hoye, Tyler Jones
Elsewhere
Picks for MLB
MLB rules and settlement
These two, other days
- Pirates Secure Series Win Over CardinalsSep 24, 2026
- Cardinals Defeat Pirates 5-1 in PNC Park ShowdownSep 23, 2026
- Pirates Shut Out Cardinals in Key MatchupSep 22, 2026
- Pirates Edge Cardinals in Thrilling FinishAug 30, 2026
- Pirates Overcome Cardinals 6-2 at Busch StadiumAug 29, 2026